Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Nietzsche on Buddhism and the Will

1:40:23 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The host opens by recapping Nietzsche's praise of Buddhism as a religion more realistic, more logical and more effective than Christianity, and as the right mental training for an exhausted, declining civilization.0:21
  • The break comes over ethics: Nietzsche grants that Buddhism suited its time and place, but the prospect of a European Buddhism emerging from the death of God haunts him as another failed outcome.3:51
  • Reading Gay Science 346, he shows Nietzsche calling man as world-denying principle an extravagant error, then turning the knife on himself by asking whether despising those who judge the world is not one more step into pessimism.9:46
  • To give the Buddhist side its full weight, the host reads the Asu Sutra from the Samyutta Nikaya, where the tears shed over the deaths of mother, father, brother, sister, son and daughter across countless rebirths exceed the water in the four great oceans.24:12
  • He closes with Will to Power 23, where active nihilism is a sign of strength and Buddhism is weary nihilism which no longer attacks, and then with Ajahn Chah and Zarathustra both telling the listener to taste the fruit and abandon the teacher.1:33:38

Brief overview

Nietzsche admires Buddhism's realism yet condemns it as passive nihilism, because he affirms earthly life instead.

  1. Justification of life lies inside or outside itFor the Buddhist the justification for life cannot lie within life; for Nietzsche it cannot lie outside of it.
  2. Nietzsche rejects free will and determinism alikeBuddhism affirms causality and free will together; Nietzsche rejects causality itself, and with it both doctrines.
  3. Buddhism's endpoint is passivity, hence nihilismBuddhist valuations do inspire action, but the action aims at non-action, which Nietzsche calls the perfect cow and the last man.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why does Nietzsche ultimately reject Buddhism if he admires it so much?

Because Buddhist valuations do inspire action, but the course they set ends in passivity, so Nietzsche judges it ultimately nihilistic. He wants valuations whose actions make further action and further valuing possible, whereas the Buddhist acts only to uproot karma and get out of action entirely.

Answered around 1:06:53
Where does Nietzsche agree with Buddhist teaching about the self?

Epistemologically he finds the Buddhist non-identity of the self largely accurate. In Thus Spoke Zarathustra the self is both a multiplicity and a unity, a flock and a shepherd. His deconstruction lacks the rigor of the five skandhas or dependent origination, but shares that mindset.

Answered around 1:07
Why does Nietzsche call Gautama Buddha the great physiologist?

Because Buddha determined the ideal remedy for the exhausted, hypersensitive nerves of a dying people, showing them how to serenely accept their extinction. The Nietzschean critique is that a healthy way of living through decline, or of facing death, gets mistaken for health in general.

Answered around 4:33
What does Nietzsche mean by a European Buddhism?

It is the outcome that haunts him: during the interregnum of values opened by the dawning awareness of the death of God, the devaluation of all values, Europe settles into Buddhism instead of a new valuation. Another failed outcome, another repetition of ascent and decline.

Answered around 3:51
Why is Buddhism more pessimistic than Christianity in Nietzsche's view?

Because the notion of a perfect existence haunts Christianity: Eden's ideal life is promised to return after the day of judgment, and life is unsatisfactory only through original sin. In Buddhism individuated existence is inherently unsatisfactory, with no satisfactory form and no eternal existence either.

Answered around 15:17
What test does Nietzsche offer for affirming the eternal recurrence?

Have you ever had a high moment, a moment so exalted that you would put the entirety of your life back on the table for its sake? To wish your whole life to return, saying you would do nothing differently, some moments must be worth the cost.

Answered around 21:18
Can anyone judge whether existence is worth anything?

No. Quoting Twilight of the Idols, judgments and valuations of life, whether for or against, cannot be true; their only value is that they are symptoms, and per se such judgments are nonsense. A living man is a contending party, the object in dispute, not a judge.

Answered around 22:33
Where does the belief in cause and effect come from, for Nietzsche?

Causalism derives from the free-will doctrine: we first take the will, the intention, as the cause of action. The doctrine of the will was invented for punishment, by priests at the head of ancient communities; men were thought free so they might be judged and held guilty.

Answered around 37:21
Why does Nietzsche call Pyrrho a Buddhist for Greece?

Pyrrho rebels against the reigning Platonic and Socratic faith in the identity of reason, virtue and happiness. He does not seek happiness but indifference, tranquility, apathy, meekness, a state neither happy nor unhappy, and like the Buddha he arrives after centuries of philosophical quarrels, distrusting intellect.

Answered around 59:26
Why is Buddhism so popular in the secular West now?

It appeals to post-Christian and post-religious Westerners because its morality is beyond good and evil, presented as a means to an end, and its metaphysics is largely taken as optional. It also integrates easily into capitalist societies as a safety valve, like Amazon's warehouse mindfulness booth.

Answered around 1:28:32
Key Quote

“And so the justification for life for the Buddhist can't lie within life, whereas for Nietzsche it can't lie outside of it.”

— Nietzsche on Buddhism and the Will, at 9:17▶ listen at 9:17
Key Quote

“It is an evil act to tell people there is no causality because you're deceiving people.”

— Nietzsche on Buddhism and the Will, at 45:26▶ listen at 45:26
Key Quote

“He says Pyrrho is a Buddhist for Greece.”

— Nietzsche on Buddhism and the Will, at 1:01:50▶ listen at 1:01:50

Cite this

“Nietzsche on Buddhism and the Will.” https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO6663464815.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/nietzsche-on-buddhism-and-the-will.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?