Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost

38:38 recording · EN · 8 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In 2011 Lariat Alhassan ran Lark Lux Paint alone out of her car in Abuja, losing big orders because she had no office to invite clients to.4:55
  • Finance minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, facing 8 million young Nigerians who needed jobs and banks unwilling to lend to one-person firms, decided to simply hand entrepreneurs cash through a nationwide business-plan contest called You Win.7:24
  • World Bank researcher David McKenzie told them to pick many winners at random, which both blunted accusations of favouritism and turned the program into an experiment; 24,000 people applied, 6,000 reached the semifinals, and Lariat won 10 million naira, about $65,000, which she used to hire staff and rent a showroom.10:14
  • The World Bank evaluation found the 1,200 winners created 7,000 lasting jobs for $60 million, roughly $8,500 per job, prompting Chris Blattman to ask whether it was the most effective development program in history.14:19
  • In Busia, Kenya, Michael Kramer's four-year textbook trial across 100 schools raised no average test scores, only those of already-strong students, an unexpected result that redirected aid toward remedial education and made the town a hub of randomized trials, work that later won Kramer, Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo the Nobel Prize.23:41

Brief overview

Giving Nigerian entrepreneurs cash grants and testing aid with randomized trials in Kenya both proved remarkably effective.

  1. Cash grants beat loans where credit is brokenNigerian banks could not judge one-person firms, so You Win gave grants instead, and the winners created 7,000 jobs at $8,500 each.
  2. Randomness bought both fairness and evidencePicking many winners at random defused fears of connections deciding the money, and let the World Bank evaluate the program as a real experiment.
  3. Surprising results redirect millions in aidFree textbooks lifted only the strongest students' scores, pushing governments and aid groups toward remedial education instead.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What was Nigeria's You Win competition and how did it work?

The Youth Enterprise and Innovation Competition was a nationwide federal jobs-creation project. Anyone could apply online with a business idea; semifinalists were called together for business training and wrote full business plans, and winners were handed piles of cash rather than loans. Some 24,000 applied and 6,000 reached the second phase.

Answered around 6:40
How much did Lariat Alhassan win and what did she do with it?

Lariat got 10 million naira, about $65,000, more than ten times what she would earn in a year. She hired salespeople and marketing people and rented a proper showroom she furnished proudly. Before that she sold paint out of her car, her only other employee a security guard.

Answered around 12:49
What did the World Bank evaluation of You Win find?

The report looked at Lariat and the 1,200 other winners and found they had created 7,000 real jobs that stuck around for years. The whole thing cost $60 million, which works out to $8,500 per job created. Chris Blattman asked in his blog post whether this was the most effective development program in history.

Answered around 14:19
How were the You Win winners actually chosen?

David McKenzie, of the World Bank research group, suggested picking them randomly: look at the business plans, pull out the few that seem great, throw out the terrible ones, then choose at random after that. Because many winners were random, the World Bank could later evaluate the program like a real experiment.

Answered around 10:17
How did Nigeria keep the contest money from going to insiders?

The worry was that officials would hand the money to friends, family and connections, so only connected people would ever win. They found judges outside the government and outside Nigeria to do the grading, and took the names off the applications so judges would not know who was who.

Answered around 9:46
Why is it so hard for small African businesses to borrow?

Banks elsewhere do cash flow lending: you show your cash flow and they lend against it. Many African businesses keep no records, no electronic books, no Excel spreadsheet, and being informal they file no taxes, so there is no tax return either. Visiting each business to check is very costly.

Answered around 17:18
What is the missing middle?

It is the absence of mid-sized businesses by employee count. There are lots of very small firms with one or two employees, and a bunch of big ones in the hundreds, but the set in between, with roughly 5, 10, 15 or 20 employees, is missing.

Answered around 36:27
What did the textbook study in Busia find?

Michael Kramer expected test scores to rise as each group of the 100 schools got textbooks, but there was no difference at all in average scores. Looking again at the data, he saw textbooks helped only students who already scored highly, which pushed education reformers toward remedial education instead.

Answered around 23:43
What did the deworming study in Busia show?

Ted Miguel, one of Michael Kramer's students from Harvard, evaluated giving schoolchildren medicine for parasitic worms free, when a lot of groups were charging for it. Treated kids were far more likely to attend school, and a follow-up showed better jobs and higher incomes later in life. Treatment is now standard across Kenya.

Answered around 26:16
What is a randomized control trial?

It is a way of studying the impact of something: you split a study population into two groups randomly, one group gets the intervention and one does not. That lets you estimate the impact of the program very cleanly. Such trials are expensive and take a lot of time.

Answered around 35:39
Key Quote

“I was everything except the security.”

— Lariat Alhassan, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 5:20▶ listen at 5:20
Key Quote

“That only people who are connected get a chance and ordinary people will not.”

— Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 9:35▶ listen at 9:35
Key Quote

“I felt I couldn't even control my emotions.”

— Lariat Alhassan, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 12:29▶ listen at 12:29
Key Quote

“I remember reading it, and my eyes kind of popping out of my head”

— Chris Blattman, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 14:02▶ listen at 14:02
Key Quote

“I think it got to the point where any white person in town would be affiliated to us.”

— Carol Nikesa, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 25:53▶ listen at 25:53
Key Quote

“Oh, absolutely. Every day, Robert.”

— Tavneet Suri, Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost, at 33:21▶ listen at 33:21

Cite this

“Nigeria's Free Money Business Boost.” https://npr.simplecastaudio.com/7dda0db1-b7e8-490c-b09a-f22fdeb30a87/episodes/bbf7b35a-7b93-48b7-a34b-ab4db08ffcd9/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_d0994f2aa43ca2741202d9b391a54c16_37095626.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/nigeria-s-free-money-business-boost.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?