A $30 ATM hammer robbery in Calgary led to Tara McDonald's murder and Trevor Stang's conviction.
On February 17, 2000, at about 9:30 p.m., a man using a Bank of Montreal ATM was struck from behind repeatedly with a hammer. He staggered to a gas station for help, needed surgery for multiple depressed skull fractures, and survived. His wallet with about $30 and his red Toyota Corolla were stolen.
Answered around 3:54The attacker's face was captured on the bank's CCTV. Officers who worked Forest Lawn in the late 1990s recognized him as an opportunistic career criminal known for commercial break and enters, car thefts, simple drug possession and public intoxication. A released sketch then brought well over 60 tips confirming the same man was wanted for both crimes.
Answered around 11:12There were no eyewitnesses to the Subway attack, so police had an officer draw a sketch from the bank CCTV and an old mugshot, yet told media witnesses had come forward. Nancy Hixt calls this essentially lying to the public. Deputy Chief Cliff O'Brien said today they would describe it as someone believed to have information.
Answered around 15:11After a week of 24-hour surveillance, covert officers saw Stang heading toward the area where both crimes happened. At 5:30 a.m. on February 24, 2000, he was walking alone on 17th Avenue with few people around, and detectives arrested him. He was initially charged only for the ATM attack and robbery; his clothing went to the crime lab.
Answered around 18:40Carol said Stang left to get drugs and returned with $30 and a small red Toyota Corolla. Later he came back with a steel box holding a couple hundred dollars and papers bearing the Subway logo. They used cocaine together, and after seeing news of the homicide she tried to clean and dispose of evidence.
Answered around 24:31On February 27 at 3:30 a.m., Carol Stang led the lead detective through a hole in a fence behind blue condos near the railway tracks. The handle of a ball-peen hammer was poking out of the snow. Police knew it was legitimate because the hammer was holdback information never made public. She had scrubbed it clean.
Answered around 31:02In spring 2001, before a judge alone, Stang pleaded guilty to robbery and not guilty to attempted murder. Blood on his jeans was DNA-linked to the ATM victim. He was found guilty of aggravated assault but acquitted of attempted murder, receiving 10 years. His appeal of the sentence was dismissed by the Alberta Court of Appeal.
Answered around 41:01The defence argued manslaughter, a robbery gone bad. After nearly three weeks of evidence, the jury deliberated five hours. Prosecutor Jonathan Hack said jurors were not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of enough planning or premeditation for first degree, but found an intent to kill or to cause bodily harm while reckless whether death ensued.
Answered around 46:04Stang was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 18 years. By then he had about 40 convictions. He was later convicted of an additional robbery of a cab driver hit with a sledgehammer in 1999, stealing the cab and $83, with that time to be served consecutively.
Answered around 47:20No. The Parole Board of Canada's 2023 decision said Stang poses a high risk of re-offending, his motivation to change is inconsistent and his gains minimal. He had no physical altercation since 2020 and is stable on opioid substitution therapy, but lacks halfway house acceptance and community support. He had not received day or full parole.
Answered around 51:21“There really was no reason to strike a person in the back of the head. Simply brandishing it and demanding money would have been sufficient.”
“We've had hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of tips in from the public.”
“it is just someone who is a means to an end.”
“But for attempted murder, the only intent that works is intent to kill.”
“She would help anyone. I mean, if he demanded the money, she probably would have made him a sandwich to go with it.”
“Night Shift: Calgary Bank Attack.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/CORU8584203610.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/night-shift-calgary-bank-attack.html.