Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Odysseus and Calypso

1:09:39 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Tom and Dominic continue their Odyssey series because Christopher Nolan's film goes on general release on the 17th, opening with Dame Edna voicing Athena in Daniel Mendelsohn's translation of Book 1.2:04
  • Odysseus, sole survivor of his 12 ships, has spent seven years as Calypso's captive on Ogygia because he blinded Poseidon's son Polyphemus, and with Poseidon away among the Ethiopians, Athena gets Zeus to send Hermes while she herself goes to Ithaca.5:54
  • Twenty years after Odysseus left, suitors devour his household while Penelope stalls them by unpicking Laertes' shroud each night for about five years, and Athena, disguised as Mentor, sends Telemachus to Nestor at Pylos and Menelaus at Sparta, where Proteus's report confirms his father is alive.10:22
  • Calypso releases Odysseus, who refuses her offer of immortality for Penelope; after 17 good days Poseidon wrecks his raft on the 18th, and Nausicaa and the Phaeacians of Alcinous, identified by Homer's audience with Corfu, hear his tale and carry him sleeping to Ithaca.19:58
  • Disguised by Athena as a beggar, Odysseus reunites with Telemachus, is recognised only by his dying dog Argos and by Eurycleia's sight of his scar, strings the bow and shoots through 12 axes, kills Antinous and all 108 suitors, hangs 12 maids, mutilates Melanthius, and finally wins Penelope's trust through the secret of the olive-tree bed.51:59

Brief overview

Athena steers Odysseus home to Ithaca, where disguise, the bow contest and Penelope's tests end twenty years of absence.

  1. The Odyssey begins with Athena, not with TroyThe epic opens ten years after Troy with Athena visiting Telemachus, not with Odysseus' adventures, which he narrates later at Alcinous' court.
  2. Odysseus chooses mortal Penelope over immortality with CalypsoHe tells Calypso that Penelope falls short of her beauty but he pines all his days to see the dawn of his return.
  3. The homecoming is brutal, and children's versions hide itAll 108 suitors die, 12 maids are hanged from a ship's cable and Melanthius is mutilated, a savagery Tom says is often lost in retellings.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why can't Odysseus escape from Calypso's island of Ogygia?

Calypso, whose name means she who veils or conceals, will not let him go, and Ogygia is a strange dimension she controls. Odysseus has also offended Poseidon, god of the sea, by blinding his son, the one-eyed giant Polyphemus. Poseidon is happy to leave him there to rot, with Calypso as governor.

Answered around 7:21
How did Penelope keep the suitors waiting for years?

She promised to marry one of them once she finished weaving a shroud for Laertes, Odysseus' father. She wove all day and secretly unpicked the work at night. The trick lasted about five years until one of her maids betrayed the scheme, but Penelope still held out, backed by Telemachus.

Answered around 11:18
What does Calypso offer Odysseus, and why does he turn it down?

Calypso lets him build a boat but offers him immortality if he stays. Odysseus refuses: Penelope falls short of Calypso's beauty and stature and is mortal, yet he pines all his days to travel home. He would rather live with Penelope and die than live forever with Calypso.

Answered around 20:06
Where does the story of the Odyssey actually begin?

The epic does not begin with the fall of Troy or with Odysseus setting out on his adventures. It begins with Athena going to see Telemachus, ten years after the fall of Troy and twenty since Odysseus left Ithaca, when Telemachus had been a baby and is now a young man.

Answered around 10:05
Who are the Phaeacians and what makes their island special?

They are the Odyssey's vision of an ideal society. King Alcinous and his queen greet Odysseus with great hospitality, or xenia. They have a perfect microclimate with no winter, gold and silver robotic guard dogs, and self-sailing ships that think faster than humans. Homer's audience took their island for Corcyra, now Corfu.

Answered around 26:02
How does the old nurse Eurycleia recognise the disguised Odysseus?

Penelope orders Eurycleia to wash the beggar's feet, and she sees a scar on his thigh that Odysseus got as a young man hunting boar with his grandfather. She says, truly, you are Odysseus, dear child. He puts his hand over her mouth, almost throttling her, and she keeps the secret.

Answered around 48:01
How does the contest of the bow and the twelve axes play out?

Penelope announces that whoever strings Odysseus' bow and shoots an arrow through 12 axe heads will marry her. All 108 suitors fail to string it. Odysseus, disguised as a beggar, strings it, Zeus sends lightning from a clear sky, and his arrow passes through all 12 axe heads before he shoots Antinous in the throat.

Answered around 52:17
How does Penelope finally confirm that the man is really Odysseus?

She tells Eurycleia to move the bed out of the bridal chamber. Odysseus protests that it cannot be moved, because he carved one of its posts from a living olive tree and built the chamber around it. Only the two of them knew this, so Penelope's knees give way and she embraces him.

Answered around 1:01:22
What happens to Odysseus' old dog Argos?

Argos, the hunting dog Odysseus raised as a puppy before leaving for Troy, lies on a dung heap riddled with flies outside the palace. Though nobody else recognises the disguised Odysseus, Argos raises his head, pricks his ears and wags his tail, and then dies the moment he sees his master after 20 years.

Answered around 44:37
Why has the Odyssey proved so enduring and so often retold?

It fuses gods, famous monsters, violence and Odysseus' cunning, and its plot is endlessly adaptable. Virgil's Aeneid draws on it, which influences Dante, who has Odysseus set sail again after reaching Ithaca; Tennyson reworks that in Ulysses. Films by Christopher Nolan and Ralph Fiennes continue the retellings.

Answered around 1:04:32
Key Quote

“so he would rather live with penelope and die than live with calypso and live forever”

— Tom, Odysseus and Calypso, at 21:13▶ listen at 21:13
Key Quote

“So the single most tragic moment in the Greek history of relationships between pet owners and their pets.”

— Tom, Odysseus and Calypso, at 45:16▶ listen at 45:16
Key Quote

“I think it's the fact that it has gods, it features famous monsters.”

— Tom, Odysseus and Calypso, at 1:04:01▶ listen at 1:04:01
Key Quote

“There's a savagery to it that's often lost in children's versions, I think.”

— Tom, Odysseus and Calypso, at 1:04:27▶ listen at 1:04:27

Cite this

“Odysseus and Calypso.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/GLT2882541084.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/odysseus-and-calypso.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?