Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

One Mother Two Species

1:49:08 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello and Nels Elde record Twevo episode 118 on September 10, 2025, a couple of weeks ahead of their usual monthly slot, with Nels joining from Salt Lake City.0:03
  • Before travelling to Boston and then Greece, Vincent lists his COVID-season precautions: a reusable $40 mask with a copper-infused insert, a booster taken last Saturday, high-dose flu vaccine and an already-completed RSV shot, because at over 65 he is at higher risk.4:40
  • Nels offers condolences on the death of David Baltimore, Vincent's postdoc mentor, and they revisit the 15-year-old TWiV 100 interview Vincent reposted, Baltimore's two weeks of experiments that found reverse transcriptase after Howard Temin's ten-year search, and his call to Temin so the two papers appeared back to back.10:26
  • The paper under discussion is 'One Mother for Two Species via Obligate Cross-Species Cloning in Ants', open access in Nature, from mostly European groups with senior author Jonathan Rumminger at the University of Montpellier, built over more than a decade of fieldwork, population genetics and lab colonies.24:01
  • Sequencing 390 individuals across five harvester ant species, mitochondrial data showing every male carries Ibericus mitochondria, and a year and a half watching one queen that yielded seven fertile males — two hairless with Structor DNA, five hairy with Ibericus DNA — show Messor ibericus queens clone males of Messor structor, a species that diverged about 5 million years ago and whose nearest co43:17

Brief overview

A queen ant clones males of another species, making one mother the parent of two species.

  1. One queen gives birth to two speciesIbericus queens produce both their own fertile males and fertile males whose genome is entirely Messor structor, with only the mother's mitochondria left behind.
  2. Sperm parasitism became domesticationQueens first needed wild Structor males to make hybrid workers, then evolved to clone those males themselves and could abandon the co-located species.
  3. The species rule just brokeThe authors coined a name for these females because a mother producing another species as part of her life cycle had never been seen.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Which ant species are at the centre of this cross-species cloning discovery?

The Iberian harvester ant, Messor ibericus, together with another harvester ant, Messor structor. Harvester ants are seed collectors: they go around picking up seeds, use their mandibles to nick the seeds so they will not sprout, and bring kilograms of them into the colony as nutrition to get through the winter.

Answered around 33:29
Why can't Messor ibericus queens produce workers on their own?

The paper's first subhead is that queens depend on another species' sperm: M. ibericus queens are unable to produce workers without mating with males of another species. She can still mate with fertile males of her own species, but not to get workers. Her colony holds ibericus-structor workers plus some ibericus workers.

Answered around 39:26
What is the twist that lets these colonies live far from structor?

The punchline: the queens need the sperm of the structor species to make the hybrid worker males, which are sterile, but in the twist they also produce fertile structor males themselves. That takes the whole other colony out of the mix, and in that sense they have domesticated them.

Answered around 42:42
What is sperm parasitism in ants?

Iberian harvester ant queens are known to mate with fertile males of both species and to collect that sperm. The behaviour has been seen in many ant species and is called sperm parasitism: the female, the queen, is in control, choosing in a sense biologically between the sperm she uses to make offspring.

Answered around 37:13
Where are hybrid colonies found with no Messor structor anywhere nearby?

On Sicily. Mapping both distributions, they overlap in places like southern Italy or eastern Spain on the Mediterranean coastline, but on Sicily there is only ibericus. You are on an island about 500 miles from any structor, and yet all the hybrid workers have about half their genomes appearing structor.

Answered around 44:16
Can you tell the two kinds of fertile males apart by eye?

Yes. Among the males born from Ibericus queens, the fertile hairy ones look like Ibericus, while the hybrid males have less hair, which is what Structor looks like. So they have the appearance of the other species, and that look correlates with the genetic differences underneath.

Answered around 46:28
What does mitochondrial DNA show about the males an Ibericus queen produces?

Every hybrid, and every male that appears one hundred percent structor, carries the mitochondria of the Ibericus queen. Since all mitochondria come from the egg, that rules out males sneaking in from structor colonies, and is a good piece of evidence that this female gives birth to two different species.

Answered around 47:33
How did the lab confirm a single queen produces males of two species?

They spent a year and a half watching a single queen give birth. Seven eggs turned into fertile males: two were hairless and five were hairy. When they sequenced those genomes the correlation held, the hairless ones carrying structor DNA and the hairy ones the ibericus DNA.

Answered around 48:42
Can the domesticated structor males breed back into wild structor colonies?

It does not look like it. They examined 45 structor genomes for the hybrids that would result from clonal males mating with wild-type females of their own species, and they do not see that happening. They did not do the matings themselves. Those clonal males do mate with Ibericus females.

Answered around 57:19
What name did the authors invent for these queens?

They coined xenoparity for these females, meaning they need to produce individuals of another species as part of their life cycle. Xeno means different and parity means to give birth, so a foreign birth. The hosts admit they are unsure of the pronunciation; a new name was needed for something never seen before.

Answered around 1:03:05
Key Quote

“But science is something where you all should join together and pool your expertise, not say I did it first.”

— Vincent Racaniello, One Mother Two Species, at 18:12▶ listen at 18:12
Key Quote

“And I said, oh my God, what am I doing here?”

— Vincent Racaniello, One Mother Two Species, at 20:16▶ listen at 20:16
Key Quote

“How could one mother give birth to two distinct species?”

— Nels Elde, One Mother Two Species, at 25:20▶ listen at 25:20

Cite this

“One Mother Two Species.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO118.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/one-mother-two-species.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?