Penalty kicks are a game theory contest: the least predictable side, not the best kicker, wins.
Messi is the top World Cup scorer of all time but a slightly below average penalty kicker, and he is in the running for missing the most penalties in World Cup history. From 12 yards, with only the goalie in the way, another skill decides it: game theory.
Answered around 0:15Almost everyone has a good side and a bad side, but always shooting your best side makes you predictable. So sometimes you shoot to your worst side even though your chances of scoring are lower, and you do it unpredictably. Game theory calls that a mixed strategy.
Answered around 2:07Yes. Choosing a random sequence of left and right is very hard and most people are bad at it, but professional footballers turn out to be very good at picking those random sequences. Goalkeepers, who are also often better diving one way, construct these sequences well too.
Answered around 2:54Economist Ignacio Palacios Huerta. From the 90s, as a graduate student at Chicago, he collected a database of thousands of penalties, with his wife and mother sending him videos from Spain and elsewhere. Until the 2000s almost no team kept such records, so he knew more than the clubs.
Answered around 7:02When Ronaldo pauses in his run-up he watches what the keeper does, so the keeper should never move; after that pause he usually shoots right. In the 2008 Champions League final Chelsea's goalkeeper Peter Cech followed the advice, stood big, dived right and saved Ronaldo's penalty.
Answered around 8:19Ignacio said the Manchester United keeper does not really follow a mixed strategy of randomizing: he dives too often to his right. Chelsea's players got the note, and in the shootout player after player shot to the keeper's left, with the second, third and fourth kicks going in.
Answered around 9:11Against van der Sar, either go along the ground or high into the top corner, but do not hit it mid-height. Anelka, shaken after van der Sar pointed to his own left, hit it mid-height to van der Sar's right, and the keeper saved it quite easily.
Answered around 11:13United's keeper was too predictable, but so was Chelsea: they did the most obvious thing and shot to the keeper's left every single time, never employing the unpredictable mixed strategy. That, and maybe the wet field that made John Terry slip, ultimately cost them the victory.
Answered around 11:50Shoot first. The team shooting second is often in the psychological position of having to score just to stay in the game, and in the era before penalty reports the chances of winning if you shot first were 60%. That advantage has faded now every top team has reports.
Answered around 14:43Take your time before the shot, a few seconds, rather than rushing in and shooting like England's Jamie Carrahan in 2006. Then practise under shootout conditions: teams pipe in crowd noise during training sessions, recreate the shootout and make everybody practice performing unpredictably under pressure.
Answered around 14:10“The top World Cup scorer of all time is actually a slightly below average penalty kicker.”
“Everyone who takes a penalty has a good side and a bad side, almost everybody.”
“What's happening here is that both sides are in a mirror image situation.”
“And he is creating the best database in the world of how footballers are taking penalties.”
“For example, Ronaldo, the young Cristiano Ronaldo, when he pauses in his run-up, the keeper should never move because Ronaldo watches what the keeper does.”
“They shot to the keeper's left every single time.”
“Penalty Kicks and Game Theory.” https://npr.simplecastaudio.com/43b5acee-463e-4612-95ad-d2596d9dd337/episodes/2ad4a8bb-a39b-40f0-b138-a6e6887c5f6a/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_95ddddd2c231d990b9f31ae8ae110693_17233370.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/penalty-kicks-and-game-theory.html.