Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Plastic Bag Discovery

31:42 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • On Saturday, April 24th, 2010, 64-year-old sales clerk Kathy Goble finished her shift at a high-end men's store in Charleston, West Virginia, after a day that included lunch with Dr. Harry King, the married radiologist she was having an affair with, and a screaming public fight with her co-worker's daughter Jessica Fisher over Xanax.1:03
  • Frightened of Jessica, Kathy asked shoe salesman Charles March to walk her to her SUV at 5 p.m., then visited her ex-husband David McCartney and drove on to her boyfriend Fred Farrell's apartment to clean it while he was away on a fishing trip.5:17
  • When she did not show up for work on Monday, April 26th, her son Jason called childhood friend Detective Brian Carper, who found Kathy's phone, pills and spare keys on Fred's spotless counter and grew suspicious when Fred referred to her in the past tense.7:49
  • Her friend Laura Henderson recalled the odd last words of their 8:30 p.m. call — Kathy said 'we're going into Fred's apartment' — and hours later Kathy's silver Honda SUV turned up abandoned 15 miles outside town with a white breakdown towel in the window, though the engine started fine and it had half a tank of gas.14:46
  • With Harry King's alibi confirmed by his wife, Kathy's sons cleared by polygraph and no forensic evidence in the car, the case went cold until heavy rain on April 25th, 2012 unearthed her dismembered body in Charles March's own backyard; a stalker who had become obsessed with her and killed her when she refused him, he pled guilty, was sentenced to life, and died of cancer in prison in 2014.26:03

Brief overview

The man who walked Kathy Goble safely to her car was the one who murdered her.

  1. The escort was the killerCharles March walked Kathy to her car to protect her from Jessica Fisher, and was never once considered a suspect.
  2. One word changed the caseLaura Henderson remembered Kathy saying 'we're going in', not 'I'm going in', the only sign someone was with her.
  3. No body meant no chargesCarper had several suspects but no evidence a crime had even been committed, so the case stayed cold for two years.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Who killed Kathy Goble?

Charles March, the shoe salesman from the men's store where she worked. He had walked her to her car on the day she vanished, to keep her safe from Jessica Fisher after their fight. He was never once considered a suspect in the case.

Answered around 28:58
What sentence did Charles March receive?

He was arrested on April 25, 2012 and charged with Kathy's murder. He pled guilty and was sentenced to life in prison. He did not serve it long: he died of cancer in prison just two years later, in 2014.

Answered around 29:32
How was Kathy Goble's body finally found?

On April 25, 2012, after days of rain flooded Charleston, a 911 call reported that a human body buried on the edge of town had been unearthed. The caller was the killer's son, who spotted a tied plastic bag in a sinkhole in their backyard garden.

Answered around 26:31
Why do investigators think Charles March killed Kathy?

He had a history of stalking women. Investigators believe he grew obsessed with Kathy while working alongside her at the store, and killed her when she rejected his advances. Police say he asked her to have sex that night, and her no sent him into a rage.

Answered around 29:22
What do police believe happened the night Kathy disappeared?

Around 8.30pm the killer waited outside Fred's apartment. Kathy arrived with a grocery bag, gestured him inside, then agreed to take a drive. At a house on the edge of town he asked for sex, she refused, and he tied and strangled her.

Answered around 27:15
What was strange about Kathy's last phone call?

Her friend Laura Henderson told Detective Carper that Kathy's final words before hanging up were we're going into Fred's apartment, not I'm going in. Kathy had mentioned no one else during the whole call, and Laura had no idea who was with her.

Answered around 15:20
Why did Detective Carper suspect boyfriend Fred Farrell?

Fred said it wasn't odd that Kathy left her phone, pills and spare keys behind because she was forgetful, looking away as he said it, and using the past tense while she was only missing. His apartment had also been scrubbed spotless.

Answered around 11:25
Why was Kathy's abandoned SUV suspicious to police?

It sat on the highway 15 miles outside town with a white towel in the window signalling a breakdown, but Carper started it with her spare key and it ran fine, with half a tank of gas. No blood, no struggle, no purse.

Answered around 17:30
Was Kathy's lover, Dr. Harry King, ruled out?

Yes. He admitted the affair and the San Francisco trip, and said he was home with his wife on Saturday night. His wife confirmed the alibi, and since she was clearly upset to learn about the affair, Carper did not think she would lie for him.

Answered around 24:22
What came of the lead on Jessica Fisher?

She admitted she had fought with Kathy that day because Kathy refused to give her Xanax, and swore she left the store and never saw her again. Carper believed her but asked for a polygraph; she agreed a date, never showed up, and went missing.

Answered around 22:50
Key Quote

“Not I'm going into Fred's apartment, but we're going into Fred's apartment.”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 15:31▶ listen at 15:31
Key Quote

“We, like she was with someone.”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 15:33▶ listen at 15:33
Key Quote

“Like, why would she do that?”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 18:12▶ listen at 18:12
Key Quote

“you know, I know I should have come in sooner, but I was just afraid of what was going to happen.”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 20:31▶ listen at 20:31
Key Quote

“He was the person that she trusted to keep her safe.”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 29:11▶ listen at 29:11
Key Quote

“He was her killer.”

— Mr. Ballin, Plastic Bag Discovery, at 29:14▶ listen at 29:14

Cite this

“Plastic Bag Discovery.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/814143cd-09c6-426f-920a-7be9b3dc1506/episodes/47c51b74-353e-435b-a2ee-bfe9c0f8feb4/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_895f2c1e9007b03915bf1d9bcf9cd86d_30430064.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/plastic-bag-discovery.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?