A Portland live show pairs two solved local cases: the 1958 Martin family drowning and 1990s teen robbers.
On December 7th, 1958, Ken and Barbara Martin and their three daughters, Barbie, 14, Virginia, 13, and Sue, 11, drove east from their northeast Portland home to gather evergreen boughs for wreaths. They stopped at the Paradise Snack Bar in Hood River and for gas at Cascade Locks, and were never seen again.
Answered around 17:43Archer Mayo, a Portland artist and sculptor who dives rivers for lost items as a hobby, got obsessed with the case in 2018. At the Oregon Historical Society he studied the Cascade Locks construction plans, found a 20-foot depression called the pit, and modelled water displacement with a rice diorama.
Answered around 29:57On his final dive, in August, Archer brought up artifacts tying the car to the family: the disintegrated sole of a shoe Barbara Martin wore that day, and a camera and case carrying Ken Martin's name and address. He also recovered human remains, handed to a Hood River sheriff's deputy.
Answered around 36:37A handgun found in bushes near a stolen white Chevrolet at Cascade Locks had a serial number matching a gun stolen years earlier from a Portland department store. The Martins' eldest son, away in the Navy in New York, had worked there and admitted that theft, but it was pure coincidence.
Answered around 24:18In February 1959, near The Dalles, a man found tire tracks running off a roughly 30-foot cliff into the Columbia River Pool. Investigators found no return tracks, the tread matched the Martin family car's tires, and paint on a rock along the tracks matched the car's paint.
Answered around 27:32In May 1959 the bodies of two daughters, Susan and Virginia Martin, were found floating down the river by a fisherman and his wife, and identified through dental records. That was the last solid development for 60 years, leaving two theories: a tragic accident, or the car pushed off the cliff.
Answered around 29:01Tom Curtis and Ethan Thrower, described as the most popular boys at Grant High School in northeast Portland, robbed nearly 20 businesses at gunpoint starting in November 1996. Both were track stars near the top of their class; Tom was an Eagle Scout and homecoming king, Ethan sang in the Royal Blues.
Answered around 44:07Investigators took a blood sample from the stolen Chevy Suburban the boys abandoned and sent it for testing against Ethan's DNA. In April 1998, weeks before graduation, it matched. Witnesses also remembered a Suburban fleeing the Rustica robbery, and police mapped 19 businesses targeted around Grant High School.
Answered around 1:06:21Police noticed the uptick in robberies right around Grant High School early on, but the robbery unit that would have spotted the pattern had recently been cut. Each case was investigated in a vacuum, so nobody matched the MO, the witness descriptions of two young men, and the ski masks.
Answered around 56:14Tom used a prison program to earn a college degree, served his full sentence and was released in 2009 at 29, and now lives quietly. Ethan got out in 2006, graduated from Portland State in 2009, works in Portland as a youth social worker, and wrote A Kid's Book About Incarceration.
Answered around 1:15:32“It's a comedy true crime podcast.”
“It was a cold case for over six decades.”
“Like, one person can make such a huge difference.”
“My story also takes place in Northeast Portland.”
“Pockets Are Essential.” https://27123.mc.tritondigital.com:443/OMNY_MYFAVORITEMURDERWITHKARENKILGARIFFANDGEORGI_PODCAST_P/media-session/6aac271f-21af-4a6c-af12-30055c98eef6/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/bdde8bb3-169d-43b1-91d3-b24c0047969c/ad33f63d-2168-4988-9b21-b495016f2bd5/audio/direct/t1785394973/543_-_Live_at_the_Arlene_Schnitzer_Concert_Hall_(Portland_Early_Show).mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/pockets-are-essential.html.