Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Political Fictions by Joan Didion

24:36 recording · EN · 3 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In this NRC Haagse Zaken summer series, host Iris Verhulstonk asks returning political reporter Denise Retera which cultural object shaped her view of politics, following last week's Game of Thrones episode with Liam van de Ven.0:38
  • Retera chose Political Fictions by Joan Didion, the American essayist who died in 2021, written after the New York Review of Books asked her to follow the 1988 presidential campaign between George Bush and Michael Dukakis.2:47
  • Didion's argument is that politics constantly manufactures fictional stories — tightly staged campaigns and simplified versions of reality — produced by a club of insiders, media included, inside what she calls 'the process', which values itself above any outcome for the country.7:05
  • Retera recognises this in her own work: her first Hague piece in 2022 covered Geert Wilders campaigning at an animal feed bank in Nissewaard, where he asked owner after owner about their pets until the enthusiasm visibly cost him effort, and she saw the same gap between image and reality walking Utrecht with Liliane de Ploumen and Jesse Klaver.12:59
  • She closes on image-making today — Mark Rutte's apple and bicycle at the Binnenhof, timed so three bites were always gone on arrival, and his refusal to be filmed entering a car — concluding that a journalist should show not only the stage but the script, the audience and the backstage.19:41

Brief overview

Joan Didion's Political Fictions gave Denise Retera the outsider's eye she now uses reporting The Hague.

  1. The process outranks the countryDidion argues insiders let the theoretical process eclipse the observable citizen with a real problem.
  2. Campaigns are a travelling film setOnly the location changes: Dukakis tossed a ball off every plane, with Greek dancing held in reserve.
  3. Keep the outsider's wonderRetera's aim back in The Hague is to stay close to herself and not become an insider.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What does Joan Didion mean by "the process" in politics?

Not the democratic process people know, a mechanism letting citizens say something about their country, but the machinery with which insiders decide everything. In the end it no longer depends on the outcome for the country but on the process itself: the polls, the horse race, the candidate's performance.

Answered around 7:39
What are the political fictions Didion writes about?

That politics constantly creates fictitious stories. Not constant lying, but campaigns as minutely regulated pieces of story that simplify the version of reality. She points to American presidents who drew attention away from problems at home by mixing in foreign matters. The fictions come from a club of insiders, the media included.

Answered around 7:00
Why did Didion end up covering a presidential campaign?

She had written more about real life, California in the sixties and seventies, hippie culture. Then the New York Review of Books, an American magazine on literature, culture and politics, asked her to follow the 1988 campaign of George Bush, Republican, against Michael Dukakis, Democrat. She thought: why me?

Answered around 2:34
What happens in the Insider Baseball scene with Dukakis?

In the book's first essay, Didion attends a 1988 Dukakis speech about connection, where he says he wants to be a candidate who brings people together. Just then a confused man in a camouflage hat shoulders his way past her through the crowd, murmuring he must tell the next president something.

Answered around 8:41
What is the conflict between the theoretical and the observable?

The man with the camouflage hat is the observable: a normal man with a real problem who wants to tell it to the presidential candidate. The candidate has his own theoretical story about where the country should go, without any eye for him. Didion calls this America's last true conflict of cultures.

Answered around 9:51
How does Didion describe the staging of political campaigns?

As a kind of film set that travels through the country, where only the location changes, never the story or the performance. Every time Dukakis left the plane before the waiting press he threw a ball with an employee: sporty, spontaneous, a tough guy. The producer said, we have the Greek dancing.

Answered around 11:10
How did Mark Rutte stage the apple and bicycle image?

A Nieuwsuur report, with photographers who shot him for years, showed how he directed his own image. The classic picture is Rutte arriving by bicycle at the Binnenhof with an apple; photographers knew it always had three bites, and he half admits he only started eating it just before arriving.

Answered around 20:25
What did the reporter see at Wilders' visit to the pet food bank?

Geert Wilders campaigned for the municipal elections at the animal feed bank in Nissewaard, where owners with little money could get food for their pets, fitting the PVV's animal-loving profile. A long queue waited; he asked what kind of dog it was, how old Spike was, and it visibly cost him effort.

Answered around 13:19
Where does the reporter disagree with Didion's criticism?

She shares the criticism of the process, but not all of it. Didion finds the media too focused on the politician as a person and on the horse race. The reporter thinks who politicians are matters: they are not robots, and their personalities and conflicts influence the decisions made for the country.

Answered around 18:26
What did walking with Ploumen and Klaver show about campaigning?

In that same period she walked with PvdA leader Liliane Ploumen and Jesse Klaver of GroenLinks through Utrecht as they tried to reach people on the street. On television those conversations look like people being heard; in practice it happened much less, they hurried on, and it was often uncomfortable.

Answered around 15:16
Key Quote

“Because I was absolutely no political junkie and saw myself as a journalist more as a kind of street rat.”

— Denise Retera, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 3:52▶ listen at 3:52
Key Quote

“I've got to see the next president, I've got something to tell him.”

— Denise Retera, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 9:18▶ listen at 9:18
Key Quote

“this election isn't about ideology, it's about competence.”

— Denise Retera, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 18:09▶ listen at 18:09
Key Quote

“No, it's the other way around. I eat apples on the bike.”

— Mark Rutte, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 21:20▶ listen at 21:20
Key Quote

“Then it's not original, it doesn't work. People see that.”

— Mark Rutte, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 21:37▶ listen at 21:37
Key Quote

“No, I think that's terrible. And especially from VVD-ers, getting into such a big car.”

— Mark Rutte, Political Fictions by Joan Didion, at 22:32▶ listen at 22:32

Cite this

“Political Fictions by Joan Didion.” https://content.production.cdn.art19.com/validation=1785741854,dc28b8d5-561d-5e01-adfa-c0da86bcff26,s-nlKpNhcyyhbESyizlDdTDK-3A/episodes/345b853a-b4bc-4107-aee6-5db803f28c6e/f944b764de974ec2fabd8607dd3eba5fe74bb64ab0c81b44c0fe606ec62f3c3d0f3b0987b6b2c5cf04110c0408463bf10b5cfcea5b890aea200c0a18e88b58e1/HZ%20in%20de%20zomer%20Denise%20V3.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/political-fictions-by-joan-didion.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?