Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy

48:36 recording · AUTO · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Answering two questions from Gavin Behrens, the speaker sets out to distinguish psychoanalytic psychotherapy from psychoanalysis proper and to describe how his clinical technique shifted over his career.0:00
  • He builds the first distinction on two Robert Langs papers from around 1974 or 76, "Truth therapy / lie therapy", where lie therapy rebuilds crumbling defences and resistances rather than analysing them, and he counts psychopharmacological treatment as a variety of lie therapy, against Kierkegaard's view that symptoms are messengers.2:12
  • For the second distinction he turns to Brian Bird's paper from the early 1980s, which separates ubiquitous everyday transference and the early "floating transferences" from the transference neurosis, where the patient stops talking about symptoms and becomes obsessed with the analyst and the analytic relationship, in love or in hate.11:58
  • According to Bird, Freud first defined psychoanalysis by the emergence of the transference neurosis, promoted by three to five sessions a week on the couch with a silent analyst rather than once-a-week work in a chair, and then backed away as he saw it regress into transference psychosis, with acting out, stalking, analysts having sex with patients or getting into fist fights, and a matching count25:34
  • His own position is that the transference neurosis is what distinguishes psychoanalysis from once-a-week analytic psychotherapy, illustrated by a Montreal colleague, later the only analyst in Calgary, whose teachers nearly threw him out of training for telling a new patient she did not have to fall in love with him — a view much of the field has since come around to.40:53

Brief overview

What separates psychoanalysis proper from analytic psychotherapy is deliberately evoking and analysing a transference neurosis.

  1. Truth therapy dismantles defences, lie therapy rebuilds themLangs' basic distinction: analyse resistance to reach the truth, or strengthen a collapsing resistance because the patient cannot bear it.
  2. Transference is everywhere; transference neurosis is notThe speaker has transference to his dentist and his grocery deliverer, but a transference neurosis takes months and makes the analysis itself the patient's obsession.
  3. The analyst mirrors the patient's regressionBird says every transference neurosis produces a countertransference neurosis, which is why a destabilised analyst should return to analysis, supervision, or stop practising.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What distinguishes psychoanalysis proper from psychoanalytic psychotherapy?

The transference neurosis. Analytic psychotherapy will analyze transference, but it does not set out to evoke a transference neurosis and make its analysis and resolution the central aim of the work. In ordinary once-a-week therapy in the chair, the regression into a transference neurosis is not promoted and may even be subtly blocked.

Answered around 30:14
What is a transference neurosis and how does it develop?

The patient first comes complaining of symptoms such as obsessions, compulsions, psychosomatic complaints or relationship problems. As the transference neurosis develops, they talk less about these and become focused on the analyst and the analytic relationship, which becomes the problem itself. It is like falling in love, sometimes falling in hate, and very intense.

Answered around 18:26
What is the difference between truth therapy and lie therapy?

The distinction comes from Robert Langs, a New York psychoanalyst, in a paper from around 1974 or 1976. Lie therapy is for patients who can't handle the truth: instead of analyzing defenses to dismantle them, it rebuilds crumbling defenses and strengthens resistance. Langs claims the term is not disparaging and that lie therapy has a role.

Answered around 2:39
How does a transference neurosis differ from a transference psychosis?

Following Brian Bird, a transference neurosis operates in the depressive reparative position, where reality testing and the as-if sense are retained: the patient is in love but not stalking the analyst. If it regresses into the paranoid schizoid position, it becomes a transference psychosis, and acting out, sometimes destructive, such as stalking, begins.

Answered around 23:10
Does a transference neurosis need three to five sessions a week to emerge?

No. Session frequency increases the likelihood, but a transference neurosis can emerge in once-a-week treatment, where it is harder to contain, less likely, or slower to appear. It does not always emerge; this depends on many factors, including the analyst. A matter-of-fact, very boundaried analyst makes it less likely; a more authentic, self-revealing one makes it more likely.

Answered around 37:33
What is the difference between a transference cure and an authentic cure?

An authentic cure, for Freud, means real structural change in the personality: symptoms are resolved and understood, the conflicts driving them largely resolved. In a transference cure, symptoms disappear for a time because of an idealizing attachment to the therapist, like a cult of two; if that relationship breaks down, the symptoms or similar ones quickly return.

Answered around 7:33
Why does the analyst also develop a counter-transference neurosis?

According to Byrd, whenever a patient develops a transference neurosis the analyst develops a counter-transference neurosis; the two mirror each other, with love or hate matching the patient's. If the patient loses reality testing, so may the analyst, which is why analysts sometimes end up having sex with patients or getting into fist fights in the office.

Answered around 31:08
When should an analyst avoid working with transference neurosis?

When he is in a personal crisis and destabilized, for example going for surgery, having a very ill child, going through a divorce, or after his wife has died. In such times the analyst tends to regress and is less contained, so he should go back into analysis or supervision, or withdraw from practice for a time.

Answered around 33:34
Why is psychopharmacological treatment called a form of lie therapy?

Because it is simply interested in making symptoms go away. Citing Kierkegaard, the speaker says symptoms are messengers telling us something is wrong in the soul, and we should listen to them rather than remove them. This is also why Freud gave up hypnosis: he wanted to know what purposes symptoms serve and where they originated.

Answered around 6:00
What is the difference between an erotic and an erotized transference?

The erotic transference operates in the depressive position: a tender, romantic love, with no stalking, staying on Hannah Segal's level of symbolic representation, where the analyst is like my mother. The erotized transference operates in the paranoid schizoid position, becomes concrete and leaves the as-if, at the level of symbolic equation: the analyst is my mother.

Answered around 35:35
Key Quote

“I'm not God. I don't have a crystal ball and I'm not omniscient.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 4:37▶ listen at 4:37
Key Quote

“You know, Surin Kierkegaard said, don't make the symptoms go away.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 6:12▶ listen at 6:12
Key Quote

“Transference is ubiquitous.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 12:51▶ listen at 12:51
Key Quote

“Because all falling in love is transference.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 15:16▶ listen at 15:16
Key Quote

“He sold millions of copies because people thought it was a sex manual.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 15:49▶ listen at 15:49
Key Quote

“It's now the focus. It's now the problem. The patient can't shut up about his or her analysis.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 19:22▶ listen at 19:22

Cite this

“Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/psychoanalyticthinking/Therapy_...Analysis.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/psychoanalysis-vs-psychotherapy-2.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?