Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy

48:36 recording · AUTO · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Answering a listener named Gavin Behrens, the speaker sets out to distinguish psychoanalytic psychotherapy from psychoanalysis proper and to say how his own clinical technique has shifted.0:00
  • He uses Robert Langs's mid-1970s paper 'Truth therapy / lie therapy' to divide therapies into those that dismantle defenses and those that rebuild crumbling ones, citing Freud sending away a late-middle-aged widow rather than removing symptoms he had nothing to replace.2:12
  • Turning to Brian Bird's early-1980s paper, he separates ubiquitous everyday transference from the transference neurosis, which in well-structured patients may take six months or the better part of a year and emerges sooner at four or five sessions a week.11:48
  • He warns that a transference neurosis regressing from the depressive-reparative into the paranoid-schizoid position becomes a transference psychosis with stalking and acting out, mirrored by a countertransference neurosis in the analyst, which is why an analyst in personal crisis should return to analysis, supervision, or withdraw from practice.31:08
  • He recounts a Montreal candidate, later the only analyst in Calgary, who told a prospective patient she did not have to fall in love with him and was nearly thrown out of training, and concludes that psychoanalysis proper still seeks and contains this explosive material.41:31

Brief overview

Psychoanalysis proper differs from analytic psychotherapy by deliberately evoking and analyzing the transference neurosis.

  1. Truth therapy dismantles defenses, lie therapy rebuilds themLangs's basic distinction: some patients, Freud's widow among them, cannot be given truth in exchange for their symptoms.
  2. Transference is everywhere, transference neurosis is notThe speaker has a transference to his dentist and his grocery deliverer; the transference neurosis makes the analysis itself the patient's obsession.
  3. The transference neurosis is the dividing lineAnalytic psychotherapy analyzes transference but does not set out to evoke a transference neurosis and make its resolution the central aim.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What separates psychoanalysis proper from psychoanalytic psychotherapy?

Analytic psychotherapy will analyze transference, but it does not set out to evoke a transference neurosis and make the analysis and resolution of that the central aim of the work. Psychoanalysis does: the patient comes three, four or five times a week, lying on the couch, the analyst out of sight.

Answered around 30:14
How do you know a transference neurosis is emerging?

The patient arrives complaining of symptoms: obsessions, compulsions, hysterical and psychosomatic symptoms, relationship problems. As the transference neurosis develops, the patient talks much less about those problems and becomes focused on the analysis, the analyst and the analytic relationship. They cannot shut up about it; the passion is intense.

Answered around 18:26
When does a transference neurosis turn into a transference psychosis?

When it regresses out of the depressive reparative position into the paranoid schizoid position. In the depressive position reality testing is largely retained: the patient is in love with the analyst but is not stalking him, not hiding in the bushes or peeking into windows. In the paranoid schizoid position acting out begins.

Answered around 23:17
What happens to the analyst when the patient develops a transference neurosis?

Brian Bird says the analyst develops a countertransference neurosis; the two mirror one another. The analyst falls into love or hate matching the patient's, and must contain it, not act out, and keep in mind the as-if quality so that the whole thing can be analyzed rather than lived out.

Answered around 31:08
What is the difference between truth therapy and lie therapy?

Robert Langs made this the basic distinction. Instead of analyzing defenses in order to dismantle them, lie therapy is devoted to building back defenses that are crumbling; instead of analyzing to get beneath the resistance, it strengthens and rebuilds the collapsing resistance, sparing patients truths they may find unbearable.

Answered around 3:54
What is the difference between an authentic cure and a transference cure?

Authentic cure means real structural change in the personality: symptoms are resolved and understood, the conflicts driving them more or less resolved, the person transformed. In a transference cure symptoms disappear only through the patient's idealizing emotional attachment to the therapist, and return quickly if that relationship breaks down.

Answered around 7:33
Does a transference neurosis require three to five sessions a week?

No. Frequency increases the likelihood that one may emerge, and it may emerge much sooner at four or five times a week. A transference neurosis can still emerge in once-a-week treatment, though it may be less likely, take a lot longer, and be harder to contain.

Answered around 37:33
What is the difference between erotic and erotized transference?

The erotic transference operates in the depressive position: the patient is in love, but it is tender, romantic, and the patient is not stalking the analyst. The erotized transference operates in the paranoid schizoid position and becomes concrete, leaving the as-if: Hannah Segal's symbolic equation rather than symbolic representation.

Answered around 35:35
What should an analyst do when their own life is destabilized?

Go back into analysis or supervision, or withdraw from practice for a time. Working with a transference neurosis is particularly dangerous when the analyst faces surgery, a very ill child, a divorce or the death of a wife: he is inclined to regress and is no longer as contained.

Answered around 34:54
Does transference only happen inside therapy?

No. Freud and Freudians think transference is ubiquitous and not particular to psychotherapy; every relationship has some element of it. The speaker has a transference to his accountant, his dentist, his intimate partner, his children, even the man who delivers groceries to his porch, who is for him a feeding person.

Answered around 12:36
Key Quote

“You know, Surin Kierkegaard said, don't make the symptoms go away.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 6:12
Key Quote

“The symptoms are messengers.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 6:18
Key Quote

“Transference is ubiquitous.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 12:51
Key Quote

“Because all falling in love is transference.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 15:16
Key Quote

“They're kind of obsessed. Well, it's like a falling in love. Sometimes it's a falling in hate,”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 19:30
Key Quote

“The other thing that Byrd says is that whenever a patient develops a transference neurosis, the analyst develops a counter-transference neurosis.”

— Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy, at 31:08

Cite this

“Psychoanalysis vs Psychotherapy.” https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/psychoanalytic-thinking-with-dr-don-carveth/id1580786160. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/psychoanalysis-vs-psychotherapy.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?