Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Public Health in Crisis

1:03:51 recording · AUTO · 4 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Guest Chuck Knirsch describes his board work for the Task Force for Global Health in Atlanta and chairing the World Mosquito Program board in Brazil, where Wolbachia-carrying Aedes aegypti are released to block dengue, Zika and yellow fever.1:03
  • He details cuts to GAVI and USAID, PEPFAR no longer functioning, hundreds of millions of dollars of donated drugs and vaccines stuck in ports, and a five-year plan to hand programs to country ownership by 2030 that was compressed into five minutes after the inauguration.2:31
  • Daniel Griffin then presents a PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases paper, "Does Schistosome Infection Affect Behavior Through the Gut-Brain Axis?", from groups in Tucson, Arizona and Corvallis and Lebanon, Oregon, which infected mice with cercariae, treated them with praziquantel, and ran open field, novel object, marble burying and Morris water maze tests.9:40
  • Infected mice spent more time in the outer boundary, almost 85% against about 80% for uninfected, read as greater anxiety, and showed higher novel-object memory retention at one hour but none at 24 hours, while marble burying showed nothing and the water maze differences had overlapping error bars.24:58
  • The authors conclude they did not find a direct interaction between behavior and microbiome composition, and Christina Naula and Daniel both say a fecal transplant experiment is what the work still needs, before the episode closes with a tribute to Dixon, his teaching, his Trichinella and VEGF work, and his role in starting TWiV and TWiP.39:23

Brief overview

Schistosome-infected mice became more anxious, but the study could not link behavior change to the microbiome.

  1. Infected mice were measurably more anxiousIn the open field test they spent almost 85% of the time in the outer boundary versus about 80% for uninfected mice.
  2. The gut-brain link stayed unprovenThe microbiome shifted, but the authors found no direct interaction between behavior and microbiome composition, and no fecal transplant was done.
  3. Aid cuts put deworming and surveillance at riskGAVI and USAID cuts, PEPFAR stopped and drugs stranded in ports threaten early warning systems and programs for neglected tropical disease.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Did schistosome infection make the mice more anxious?

Yes. In the open field test, mice infected with schistosomes spent more time in the outer boundary than uninfected mice, almost 85% of the time versus about 80%, a statistically significant difference. More time at the outer boundary is read as increased anxiety or fear, and entries into the centre zone also differed.

Answered around 24:58
What did the novel object task show about memory?

Mice infected with schistosomes had higher memory retention one hour after exposure to the objects than uninfected mice, but there was no difference at 24 hours. The test assumes a mouse that remembers the familiar object spends more time checking out the new one; if it remembers nothing, both objects seem novel.

Answered around 26:23
What did the Morris water maze test find?

Infected mice had a somewhat greater corrected cumulative distance, swimming further before finding the hidden submerged platform, which the authors read as an impact on spatio-temporal memory. But the error bars all overlap, so it is not significant, and it contrasts with the enhanced one-hour memory in the novel object task.

Answered around 32:35
Did the study show the gut microbiome causes the behaviour changes?

No. The authors conclude they did not find a direct interaction between behaviour and microbiome composition in schistosome-infected mice, and suggest the two may be unrelated or too correlated to tease apart with this model. A fecal transplant, establishing the new microbiome and retesting behaviour, is the experiment that is missing.

Answered around 39:23
How does the schistosome life cycle infect people?

Paired adult male and female worms live in the venous system and evade the immune system, the female laying several thousand eggs a day. The eggs inflame the bladder with Schistosoma haematobium, or the liver with mansoni and japonica. Eggs leave via the GI tract into a snail host, and cercariae reinfect humans through skin contact with fresh water.

Answered around 11:24
Does schistosome infection provoke a cytokine response in mice?

Yes. Figure three compares infected mice, the black bars, with uninfected, the grey bars. IL-23 shows a large difference, IL-17 some, and IL-10 is up quite a bit, but not TNF-alpha. There was no association between worm burden and any cytokine, and the mice averaged about three worm pairs after praziquantel.

Answered around 22:14
How can swimmers reduce schistosomiasis risk in African fresh water?

The advice given to the children at Lake Malawi was to towel off vigorously on getting out, because the cercariae penetrate as you leave the water and the skin starts to dry, though how effective that is was never trialled. Praziquantel testing and treatment on return followed, and improving water and sanitation is the broader measure.

Answered around 13:15
How does schistosome infection affect children's behaviour?

Studies cited in the paper's introduction report deficits in school attendance, school performance and memory, and increased hyperactivity, aggression, conduct problems, anxiety and withdrawal. The panel cautions that these children likely also carry soil-transmitted helminths and other infections, and malnutrition, and that observational studies cannot separate those causes.

Answered around 40:29
Did the marble burying task show any difference between infected and uninfected mice?

No difference at all in the number of marbles fully or partially buried, and the paper carries no figure for it. Marble burying is meant to measure compulsivity or anxiety, with more burying indicating more anxiousness, so the panel judged it a nothing-to-see-here result that could still have been shown as a figure.

Answered around 31:21
What has happened to United States global health funding?

There have been cuts to GAVI and to USAID, PEPFAR is not functioning, and hundreds of millions of dollars of donated drugs and vaccines are sitting in ports without being moved. Domestically NIH, CDC and FDA are being destroyed. A five-year plan to transition programmes to country ownership by 2030 got five minutes instead.

Answered around 2:22
Key Quote

“I'm playing for the long game, and I believe in public health.”

— Chuck Knirsch, Public Health in Crisis, at 4:17▶ listen at 4:17
Key Quote

“There's not really anything conclusive, really, unless I completely missed the point.”

— Christina Naula, Public Health in Crisis, at 34:48▶ listen at 34:48
Key Quote

“Is that just an epiphenomenon or is that driving the behavior change?”

— Daniel Griffin, Public Health in Crisis, at 35:51▶ listen at 35:51
Key Quote

“We miss being Dixonized.”

— Chuck Knirsch, Public Health in Crisis, at 53:54▶ listen at 53:54

Cite this

“Public Health in Crisis.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twip/TWiP262.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/public-health-in-crisis.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?