Ransomware negotiation has become a professional industry built on psychology, and paying ransoms keeps funding the attacks.
According to Curtis Minder, it is a game of human psychology. Negotiators remember hackers are people with emotions, acknowledge their skill in pulling off the attack, then cry poor, saying the company lacks the means for such a large payment. They also challenge how the hackers arrived at their number.
Answered around 11:16Positional bargaining means trading numbers back and forth until meeting in the middle. Curtis Minder says doing it too soon means paying more, because once you put out a number you are already talking numbers. The goal is to get hackers to come down a couple of times before you even counter offer.
Answered around 12:19Hackers break into a company's networks, steal and encrypt its data, and offer to sell the encryption key back for a price. They typically say pay a set amount to get your data back, and if you refuse, they will post all of it on the dark web for sale.
Answered around 3:06It normally engages a breach coach at a law firm, who connects it with others: a cybersecurity incident response firm to assess backups and rebuild systems, possibly a negotiator to talk hackers down, and the cyber insurance company, which decides what will and will not be covered. It is described as a $300 billion US industry.
Answered around 8:44They almost always demand Bitcoin or Ether because cryptocurrency payments are not reversible. Once you send Bitcoin to the hacker's wallet address, you cannot call your bank and ask to reverse the transaction because it was extortion. Once paid, that money is gone and cannot be recovered.
Answered around 7:00Damages in 2025 were expected to reach $57 billion US worldwide. LockBit, which hacked Indigo and SickKids, allegedly made at least $100 million in ransom demands. NetDiligence, which studies cyber insurance claims, reports payments as high as $75 million US, while hackers ask for up to $150 million US.
Answered around 2:10Not necessarily. An employee of DigitalMint, a Chicago company, working as a negotiator was indicted in the US for allegedly participating in ransomware attacks. Cybersecurity firms often recruit talent from the dark web, and former black hat hackers crossing over share the same skill set, which could be used for the wrong reasons.
Answered around 14:26Ransomware groups claim they have a reputation to uphold, since nobody would pay if they failed to deliver, and negotiations read like business deals. Law enforcement says there is no guarantee: criminals may still sell data on the dark web, re-attack, or re-extort victims by demanding a second ransom payment.
Answered around 16:18Experts suggest first requiring organizations to report every ransom paid, to whom and how much, to a government agency, discouraging unnecessary payments. Later, an oversight board could review and approve payment requests. Over years, companies would improve backups and preventative security, and criminals would get the signal that victims are closed for business.
Answered around 18:41All organizations, including hospitals, infrastructure utilities, and companies like Indigo and SickKids Hospital. Experts say small to medium sized enterprises are frequently targeted because they lack resources for preventative security. The manufacturing sector has also been hit lately, forcing paused operations, while hospitals may have to cancel cancer surgeries.
Answered around 3:38“It's a $300 billion US industry.”
“Apparently, according to Curtis Minder, who I spoke to for this piece, it's really just a game of human psychology.”
“You know, when you read these negotiations, they read like business negotiations.”
“It's a question of when are you going to get hacked and not if you're going to get hacked.”
“Because there's, you know, there's a saying an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.”
“Ransomware Negotiation Tactics.” https://afp-119681-injected.calisto.simplecastaudio.com/8b638145-9d42-4003-985c-054905c039a5/episodes/30a1bfa3-a853-4a3d-b496-0fedce0af3b3/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_f852fc814083a0c85c16669102f9da67_21404435.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/ransomware-negotiation-tactics.html.