Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Rats That Learned to Remember

41:36 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In 1920 Harvard psychologist William McDougall put genetically identical wistar rats in a water maze with a moving bright exit that shocked them and a safe dark one, and his first generation needed 165 tries to learn the rule.3:28
  • Later generations improved without training: 141 tries, then 118, then 56 by generation eight, and just 20 tries by generation 30 — eight times faster — and even a line bred deliberately from the slowest learners improved at the same rate.5:34
  • F.A.E. Crew at Edinburgh set out in 1923 to debunk him and found his untrained control rats, genetically unrelated to McDougall's, averaged 25 tries on day one, and W.E. Agar got the same result over 20 years in Melbourne.9:34
  • Rupert Sheldrake, watching a bean plant grow toward a pole that would not be installed for two days, proposed that nature has a memory — morphic fields that any similar system can resonate with — and Nature's editor John Maddox answered his 1981 book by calling it the best candidate for burning in years, a campaign that ran through a 2008 stabbing in Santa Fe and TED pulling his 2013 talk.17:54
  • The host's verdict: the hundredth-monkey story was invented by Bligh Watson, the crystals have a seed-crystal explanation and the crossword and TV results are small and contested, but the rat data is real, replicated on another continent, and epigenetics suggests the effect may be genuine even if the cause is unknown.27:44

Brief overview

Rats, birds and crystals seemed to learn faster worldwide; Sheldrake's morphic resonance explains it, and cost him everything.

  1. Three labs, three continents, the same impossible resultMcDougall's 165 tries fell to 20 over 30 generations, and Crew's unrelated untrained rats started at 25.
  2. Morphic resonance: nature remembers and repeatsSheldrake's claim is that once a system organizes itself, the pattern is easier for every similar system afterwards, anywhere.
  3. Suppression made the idea biggerThe Nature book-burning editorial turned the book into a bestseller, and the banned TED talk got millions of views elsewhere.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is morphic resonance?

Sheldrake's idea is that nature has a memory: when any system organizes itself - a crystal forming, a plant growing, an animal learning - it creates a morphic field. A similar system can resonate with that field and access the memory, and the more it is accessed the stronger it gets, across space and time, no physical connection required.

Answered around 17:54
What did McDougall's 1920 rat maze experiment involve?

Harvard psychologist William McDougall put genetically identical Wistar rats in a water maze with a brightly lit exit that delivered an electric shock and a safe dark one, and he moved the bright exit left or right so direction could not be memorized. The first generation averaged 165 tries before learning dark equals safe, light equals pain.

Answered around 3:28
How much did the rats improve over thirty generations?

Generation two averaged 141 tries, generation three 118, and by generation eight 56. The improvement accelerated: eight more generations brought it to 41, eight more to 29, and by generation 30 rats solved the maze in just 20 tries, eight times faster than their ancestors' 165 attempts.

Answered around 5:16
Did other scientists replicate McDougall's rat results?

F.A.E. Crew, an Edinburgh geneticist who thought McDougall sloppy, repeated it in 1923 with the same water maze, different genes and a control group. His trained rats mastered it in about 20 tries; the untrained ones, who should have needed 165, averaged 25. W.E. Agar in Melbourne ran a similar study for 20 years with the same result.

Answered around 8:38
What happened when McDougall bred only the slowest learners?

He split the colony and mated the worst performers from each generation, expecting them to stay slow or get worse. Instead they got faster too, improving at the same rate as the randomly bred line, the slowest learners produced offspring that learned faster than their parents, generation after generation.

Answered around 5:48
What did blue tits learn to do with milk bottles?

Pierce the foil cap, drink the cream. That is what blue tits in Southampton, England worked out in 1920, when milk was left on doorsteps in glass bottles with foil caps. The behaviour spread all over Britain, and by the 1940s every blue tit was doing it.

Answered around 10:56
Why can't copying explain the blue tits returning to the trick?

Wartime aluminium went to aircraft, so foil caps were replaced by wood or harder metal the birds could not pierce. They live only a couple of years, so by war's end every bird that had ever pierced a cap was dead. Yet when foil returned, birds that had never seen the trick pierced them again across Britain.

Answered around 11:44
How did the journal Nature react to Sheldrake's book?

In September 1981 John Maddox, editor of Nature, then the most prestigious science journal in the world, wrote an editorial calling the book the best candidate for burning there's been for many years, comparing it to Mein Kampf for potential damage, and calling it pseudoscience and heresy. The editorial made the book a bestseller.

Answered around 20:38
What is the main scientific objection to morphic resonance?

Morphic resonance requires information transfer with no energy cost, which violates the law of conservation of energy. The counter offered is quantum physics: two particles separated by a room or a galaxy respond to each other instantly, confirmed in the 1980s, ignoring both conservation of energy and the speed of light.

Answered around 29:50
Is the hundred monkeys washing sweet potatoes story true?

No, it is completely made up. The author took real observations from primatologists and added a little fiction for fun. The story, from the 1979 book Lifetide, had monkeys on Koshima Island washing sweet potatoes and claimed that once a hundred learned it, monkeys on other islands started too.

Answered around 27:47
Key Quote

“Knowledge had crossed the ocean, and no one could explain how.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 1:19▶ listen at 1:19
Key Quote

“165 attempts, they mastered in 20. They were eight times faster at learning the same task.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 5:40▶ listen at 5:40
Key Quote

“But the untrained rats should have averaged 165 tries.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 9:30▶ listen at 9:30
Key Quote

“This was a skill somehow encoded into the species itself.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 12:18▶ listen at 12:18
Key Quote

“Maybe nature has a memory.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 17:54▶ listen at 17:54
Key Quote

“He called it the best candidate for burning there's been for many years.”

— AJ, Rats That Learned to Remember, at 20:53▶ listen at 20:53

Cite this

“Rats That Learned to Remember.” https://dcs.megaphone.fm/QCD4932582503.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/rats-that-learned-to-remember.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?