Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Roger Huber Case

45:54 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • A 16-year-old special education student the hosts call Emily began journaling in January 2005 in Lockport, New York, and wrote that her friend Megan, 17, was in a secret relationship with an adult in law enforcement named Roger.0:59
  • A school administrator traced the name to 41-year-old Roger Huber, a correctional officer at the local jail, and Investigator Joe Taylor of the Niagara County Sheriff's Office opened a formal investigation, since New York's age of consent is 17 and the only question was when the relationship started.2:40
  • Huber's live-in girlfriend, 33-year-old Cheryl Rucci, who had a learning disability and whose cousin put her mental age at about 16, told Taylor that she and Roger had sexually assaulted a 14-year-old girl together in the summer of 1999, a statement that made her both the key witness and a defendant.9:33
  • On August 9th, 2005, hours after hearing deputies had come to serve her with a grand jury subpoena, Cheryl disappeared from her apartment complex leaving her shoes and purse behind, and her family says the same department Roger worked for wrote her off as a fugitive who had run away.12:39
  • Roger was indicted on 21 counts, pleaded guilty to second-degree attempted rape and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child, served 16 months to four years, later married Megan, and Cheryl is still missing twenty years on while a witness the hosts call Amy says her sighting that night was dismissed.15:46

Brief overview

Cheryl Rucci vanished in 2005 before testifying against Roger Huber, a corrections officer.

  1. The witness vanished before the grand juryDeputies came to serve Cheryl's subpoena on August 9th, 2005, and she was reported missing the next night.
  2. Same department investigated its own officerThe Niagara County Sheriff's Office handled Cheryl's disappearance while Roger Huber worked there, and her family says she was labelled a fugitive.
  3. A road-side sighting was brushed asideAmy reported a teal four-door car, a woman mouthing "go, go, go" and, weeks later, a foul odor from the same woods; she says a detective told her Cheryl wasn't worth looking for.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
When and how did Cheryl Rucci disappear?

On August 9th, 2005, Cheryl was at a cookout at her apartment complex when friends said Niagara County Sheriff's deputies had come to serve her a grand jury subpoena. She got upset, called family, and left her mom a voicemail. Nobody could reach her, and her family reported her missing on August 10th.

Answered around 12:39
What did Cheryl Rucci confess to investigators about Roger Huber?

Cheryl told Investigator Joe Taylor that in the summer of 1999 she and Roger Huber together sexually assaulted a 14-year-old girl whose family Roger had been close to since she was a baby. She gave enough detail to hand Roger over, while exposing herself to the same fate, apparently driven by fear of losing her daughter.

Answered around 9:33
What was Roger Huber indicted for?

On September 1st, a grand jury indicted him on 21 counts, 20 of which stuck: rape, sodomy and sexual abuse tied to the 1999 allegation, endangering the welfare of children, unlawfully dealing with a child for giving alcohol to a minor, criminal contempt, and a firearm charge. A motel charge was dropped because it was in another county.

Answered around 15:38
What sentence did Roger Huber receive?

After a defense witness flipped, Roger pleaded guilty to second-degree attempted rape and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child. At sentencing on June 5th, 2006, the judge called him a predator who preys on young girls and gave the maximum: 16 months to four years in state prison.

Answered around 18:55
What did the witness Amy see the night Cheryl vanished?

Around 10 to 10:15 p.m. on a rural road off State Route 78, Amy stopped behind a teal four-door car. A scared woman inside mouthed "go, go, go" as a huge Hulk-like man walked out of the brush. Amy fled, called for help, and returned to find the car dark and both people gone.

Answered around 28:04
Did Roger Huber have an alibi for the night Cheryl disappeared?

Roger supposedly was at the movies with his and Cheryl's daughter. But the daughter told the hosts the movie night was canceled and Roger dropped her and her brother at his mother's house, leaving a stretch of time when, from her point of view, nobody knows where Roger was.

Answered around 24:01
Why does Cheryl's family believe she did not run away?

She had no cell phone, credit cards or driver's license. Her shoes and purse were left in her clean apartment. She was devoted to her daughter and called family multiple times a day, so going silent was out of character. Her last confirmed sighting was around 9 p.m., possibly barefoot, taking out the trash.

Answered around 21:51
What searches have been done to find Cheryl Rucci?

Investigators followed more than 200 leads, did land searches, sonar searches in a nearby lake, used cadaver dogs, and searched Roger's foreclosed home, finding nothing. In 2011 the sheriff said she was believed to be a victim of foul play. A search and rescue team searched Amy's area in November 2024 without finishing.

Answered around 26:20
What happened to Roger Huber after he left prison?

Released on January 15th, 2010, he registered as a sex offender but violated the rules by moving in with his new wife Megan, the former student, without telling anyone, getting five years' probation from 2012. He was discharged early on February 25th, 2015, then arrested in August 2015 for driving under the influence of drugs.

Answered around 38:27
How can someone share information about Cheryl Rucci's disappearance?

Contact the Niagara County Sheriff's Office at 716-438-3393 or submit an anonymous tip through their website. Investigator Ed Finley, the current lead on the case, said even small information, like a rumor that's been passed around, can matter if it gives investigators something to follow.

Answered around 44:17
Key Quote

“Tell Roger Huber to leave my students alone.”

— Ashley Flowers, Roger Huber Case, at 2:55▶ listen at 2:55
Key Quote

“And does this department know about Roger's case?”

— Britt, Roger Huber Case, at 14:27▶ listen at 14:27
Key Quote

“that Cheryl was just a crackhead whore.”

— Ashley Flowers, Roger Huber Case, at 14:04▶ listen at 14:04
Key Quote

“I think you are a threat. I think you are a predator.”

— Ashley Flowers, Roger Huber Case, at 19:08▶ listen at 19:08
Key Quote

“I have three beautiful, naked women in front of me and took advantage of an opportunity.”

— Ashley Flowers, Roger Huber Case, at 19:28▶ listen at 19:28
Key Quote

“She was saying, go, go, go.”

— Ashley Flowers, Roger Huber Case, at 29:07▶ listen at 29:07

Cite this

“Roger Huber Case.” https://rsv.simplecastaudio.com/ec74d48c-cbf1-4764-923e-7d584dce50fa/episodes/1cd192ba-560f-4c5b-b1d8-8cd31028a2ad/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_03877863004e3246bedcf34f04306dc5_44062127.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/roger-huber-case.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?