Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Roos's Web of Lies

59:33 recording · EN · 8 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Social workers Ebbe and Natasja of Stichting Syrins heard Roos in the earlier podcast, recognised her voice and contacted the makers.2:52
  • Last April someone calling herself Marlou asked their anonymous chat whether a late abortion was still possible, said her GP father had made her pregnant, kept adding details that did not add up, and after Syrins reported to Veilig Thuis it emerged she was not who she said she was; the team reckons it spent some 20 hours on her.4:32
  • At Proud To Be Me, community manager Danielle de Jong describes a girl who held the eating-disorder community for months, around whom an aunt and later a neighbour appeared, and who was written up as dying after a fall down the stairs before Danielle deleted the account.15:12
  • Jim van Os of Psychozenet puts doubtful conversations at 4 to 6 percent of their 1,500 chats a month and trains chatters in pattern recognition, while software company Nuity compares IP follow-up numbers across 23 aid organizations.25:26
  • Psychiatrist Mark Feldman calls the Marlotte story classic Munchausen by internet, and Nathalie, a young woman who faked abuse at school and on her internship, explains how she built email addresses as proof and how therapy ended the need.34:18

Brief overview

Fake help-seekers like Roos drain Dutch helplines, and experts call it Munchausen by internet.

  1. Fake stories cost helplines real care timeStichting Syrins estimates it spent about 20 hours on Marlou, time it could not give to people who did need help.
  2. Doubtful chats arrive weekly, not rarelySyrins has stronger suspicions once or twice a week, and Psychozenet estimates 4 to 6 percent of its 1,500 monthly chats.
  3. Munchausen by internet fits the Marlotte patternMark Feldman, who has seen hundreds of cases in 30 years, says the drive is attention, sympathy and a regained sense of control.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What story did the person calling herself Marlou tell the Syrins chat?

Someone calling herself Marlou came into Stichting Syrins' anonymous chat in April, saying she was already quite far into a pregnancy and asking whether abortion was still an option. Over several days she added details: it had happened through her father, her father was a GP, and a clinic said she was past the term.

Answered around 4:51
What made the aid workers doubt Marlou's story?

Things in her story did not add up: what she said about her visit to the abortion clinic could not be true. She also never produced the BSN number they normally need to open a file, saying each time that her passport was gone and she did not know where it was.

Answered around 8:45
How much time did this one fake case cost the Syrins team?

Ebbe and Natasja estimate, as a guess, about 20 hours spent on someone who did not need their care. That is time they could not give to people who do need it. The contact lasted only a few weeks, but they call it bizarre and frustrating.

Answered around 11:26
How often do these aid workers suspect a story is made up?

Once or twice a week they have stronger suspicions: daily is too much, weekly too little, they say. They almost never get confirmation, which is why they speak openly about Marlou here, since that story was proven fake through the Veilig Thuis report.

Answered around 13:17
How many chats on a mental health platform are doubted?

Jim van Os, professor of psychiatry and initiator of Psychosenet, cannot say exactly, but by reviewing the conversations employees had doubts about, they estimated it concerns about 4 to 6 percent of the roughly 1,500 chats the platform handles per month.

Answered around 25:26
How do trained chat workers recognise a story that is not real?

Van Os describes pattern recognition: the words people use, the stories, the things around them such as the greetings, and above all the type of story. It is often a story in which the person remains a victim, re-experienced in a strange loop, with something clearly hopeless in it.

Answered around 27:25
Can software show that one person chats with several organisations?

Matthias Freke of software company Nuity, which serves 23 aid organisations including Veilig Thuis and the GGD across some 14,000 anonymous chats, says conversations get a follow-up number linked to the IP address. Three chats from one IP can show 20 weeks pregnant one week, 40 weeks the next.

Answered around 31:16
What is Munchausen by internet?

Munchausen is described as a psychiatric practice in which people act as if they have physical or mental problems. American professor of psychiatry Mark Feldman coined the term Munchausen by internet in the nineties for people who fake a disease online; he has researched it for over 30 years.

Answered around 33:46
Why do people invent illness or abuse to helpers and neighbours?

Feldman says it is mainly attention, sympathy, care and concern, which these people never learned to ask for in a healthy way in real life. For someone who feels out of control or lacks a clear sense of identity, misleading others or taking on another identity restores a feeling of control.

Answered around 40:57
How did Nathalie make her invented stories believable?

She once said she got a shoe on her head and made a bruise with make-up. She also created email addresses for her father, her school and her psychologist, and used them when people started to worry, so the situation stayed small and no further help was brought in.

Answered around 48:12
Key Quote

“That voice, that voice, I recognize that voice.”

— Ebbe, Roos's Web of Lies, at 3:11▶ listen at 3:11
Key Quote

“And they still find it quite heartless that I deleted her account.”

— Danielle de Jong, Roos's Web of Lies, at 21:08▶ listen at 21:08
Key Quote

“It's unbelievable at times, and yet people believe it.”

— Mark Feldman, Roos's Web of Lies, at 36:01▶ listen at 36:01
Key Quote

“I once told that I got a shoe in my head and I made a blue spot.”

— Nathalie, Roos's Web of Lies, at 48:12▶ listen at 48:12

Cite this

“Roos's Web of Lies.” https://podcast.npo.nl/file/zembla-podcast/141620/op-zoek-naar-marlotte-het-vervolg-8-fakers-op-de-chat.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/roos-s-web-of-lies.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?