Two innocent men confessed under police pressure and lost a decade to a manufactured Quebec murder case.
To this day nobody knows. Maître Louis Belleau says the real assassins of Sandra Godet have never been identified, and despite the Poitras Commission, the 2003 Supreme Court judgment and the 2006 judgment acquitting Billy Taillefer, the police have constantly refused to reopen the investigation, still considering Taillefer and Duguay the culprits.
Answered around 39:14On Monday, March 12, 1990, thirty-six hours after the disappearance, Sergeant Gilles Gagné inspected the path of the Bay of Carrières, where her clothes had been found. A dozen metres from the road he noticed a leg covered with a black woollen stocking emerging from the snow. One of her brothers identified the body.
Answered around 3:02Dr. Claude Pottel, the legist, indicated that the teenager was strangled with bare hands, the neck still carrying marks characteristic of nails. He also noted traces of human bites on the breasts as well as the pubis. No traces of sperm were found on the body, but sexual assault and even rape were not doubtful.
Answered around 3:35Only one testimony was kept: a truck driver and his 14-year-old son saw a red vehicle parked on the path. Taken around car dealerships, then heard under hypnosis at the Quebec Security Service, the boy remembered a small red 4x4. His father named a fellow trucker who owned one, a certain Laurent Taillefer.
Answered around 4:28Arrested on Friday, April 27, seventy kilometres from Val d'Or, Taillefer said in the car: we didn't want to kill her, it was an accident. At the police station he added they just wanted to have fun. He described leading Sandra to his father's basement, undressing and hitting her, then removing the body in the red 4x4.
Answered around 14:13On Friday, February 1, 1991, after three months and fourteen days of deliberation, Billy Taillefer and Hugues Duguay were sentenced to life imprisonment with twenty-five years of security penalty. Their lawyers' request to move the trial had been refused, the crowd insulted them at the Val d'Or court, and defence witnesses were removed.
Answered around 23:54Its investigators discovered a series of documents hidden from the defence: statements of witnesses, and the notes of the policemen who testified about the confessions of the accused. They contained information very useful to the accused, demonstrating their innocence. The Commission asked the government to reopen the file and submit it to the Court of Appeal.
Answered around 32:28On Friday, December 12, 2003, the highest court in Canada broke the convictions of Billy Taillefer, 35, and Hugues Duguay, 33, who had just spent a dozen years in prison. The first obtained the right to a trial in appeal; for the second, the file was closed. The court relied on the official report listing the case's aberrations.
Answered around 30:26His appeal was to be heard in the same Val d'Or court, before the same judge, and he was convinced the second trial would lead to exactly the same result as the first. Facing that prospect, he asked his lawyer to negotiate a reduced sentence, pleaded guilty and received twelve years. He later explained it was out of discouragement.
Answered around 29:56In October 2024, aged 54, he was found dead at his home. According to his lawyer, this man broken by the case had committed suicide. Life in the penitentiary, lived in an extremely traumatizing way, had left him with extremely serious mental health problems that, over the years, led him to take his life in autumn 2024.
Answered around 37:59“because we focus on one point and we forget everything around, everything that is peripheral.”
“It's curious, we don't find any fingerprints, we don't find much.”
“You know, we called it the queen of proof for a very long time.”
“Because the police, Valdor, at the time, protects these people.”
“We don't know who is the real or who are the real assassins of Sandra Godet.”
“Over the years, he developed extremely serious mental health problems”
“Sandra Godet Murder Case.” https://files.audiomeans.fr/audio/5401ff29-bb88-4ca3-b5c9-9a36e3afc76e/98946606-b153-4687-9e85-4646bd542bf3.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/sandra-godet-murder-case.html.