Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Sardines on a Bagel

15:06 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Josh and Chuck open this Short Stuff on sardines because Chuck finally tried a tin, weeks after Josh told him to during a chat about tinned tuna and salmon for light lunches.1:19
  • Chuck's verdict: the flavor was fine and not unlike tuna, but the texture and the sight of whole little fish in a metal tray skeeved him out, so he saved his Ess-a-Bagel half; both men agree frying them Spanish tapas style or grilling them might fix it.2:47
  • The big advantage over tuna is mercury: sardines eat only plankton, so they never bioaccumulate the mercury that builds up as fish eat fish, while Josh warns that more than about one tin of tuna a week is not great and cites Jeremy Piven's mercury poisoning from too much sushi.4:23
  • On nutrition, the tiny edible bones supply roughly a third of a person's daily calcium from one tin according to the U.S. government, plus vitamin D, B12, phosphorus, selenium, protein and omega-3s that are low in saturated fat, though Josh stopped taking daily omega-3s after a recent meta-analysis linked them to higher atrial fibrillation risk for people with a family history.7:39
  • The downsides: sardines are high in purines and uric acid, so people with gout, kidney stones, high blood pressure or chronic kidney disease should go easy, and like anything canned they come with bisphenols, with the hosts reminding listeners they are not doctors or nutritionists.12:32

Brief overview

Sardines are cheap, mercury-free, nutrient-dense fish that Chuck liked the taste of but couldn't stomach.

  1. Great flavor, hard textureChuck liked how sardines tasted but couldn't get past whole little fish in a tin, and plans to fry them next.
  2. No mercury worry with sardinesThey eat plankton instead of other fish, so mercury never bioaccumulates the way it does in tuna.
  3. Nutrient-dense, but not for everyoneOne tin brings about a third of your calcium plus omega-3s, yet purines and canned bisphenols make moderation wise.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why don't sardines carry the mercury risk that tuna does?

Sardines eat plankton, not other fish. Plankton contain only very small amounts of mercury. Mercury becomes a problem because it bioaccumulates: each fish that eats another fish takes on that fish's mercury. By the time you eat a large predator fish, you may be eating a lot of it. Sardines only get the plankton's small amount.

Answered around 4:23
What nutrients and health benefits do sardines provide?

You eat the tiny bones, which are full of calcium. One tin reportedly gives about a third of the calcium a person needs, according to the U.S. government, which helps people who are lactose intolerant. Sardines also provide vitamin D, B12, phosphorus, selenium and omega-3 fatty acids, which help prevent heart disease, and they are low in saturated fat.

Answered around 7:33
Who should be careful about eating a lot of sardines?

People with gout, kidney stones or high blood pressure may want to avoid overloading on them. Sardines are high in purines, which create extra uric acid. They are also so packed with protein that they can be hard on the kidneys of people with chronic kidney disease. The hosts, who are not doctors, suggest talking to a professional.

Answered around 12:32
Should I buy sardines packed in oil or in water?

Sardines can come packed in oil or in different sauces, and some carry a lot of sodium depending on the kind you buy. The hosts recommend sardines packed in water without much added sodium. Chuck notes that with tuna packed in water, people often add so much mayonnaise to make up for the missing oil that it evens out or gets worse.

Answered around 13:38
Do canned sardines have a BPA problem?

Yes. Almost anything sold in a can probably contains some kind of bisphenol in the can itself. The hosts mention BPA and BPF, and note that cans labelled BPA-free often use replacement bisphenols instead. They say sardines are no exception, and point listeners to their earlier short episode on BPAs.

Answered around 14:14
Why do some people find sardines hard to eat even if they like the taste?

Both hosts found the flavor fine, similar to tuna and nothing like anchovies, but struggled with the texture. Sardines come as whole little fish in a tin rather than ground up like tuna or salmon, and you eat the tiny bones, which dissolve in with the rest of the fish. They smell far fishier than they taste.

Answered around 2:49
How can you cook sardines to make the texture easier to handle?

Josh found you can fry them, the way they are served as Spanish tapas, hoping that crisping them up makes them easier to eat. Chuck suggests grilling them, or putting them on a bagel and toasting it in the toaster oven. In Portugal and Spain they are grilled or put on pizza toast.

Answered around 3:34
Is it true omega-3 supplements can raise heart risk?

Josh cites a recent large meta-analysis finding that, for people with a family history of heart disease, taking omega-3s actually increased the risk of developing it, while it had a protective effect for those who already have heart disease. It was one study, but not dismissed in the scientific press, and it made him stop taking omega-3s daily.

Answered around 8:20
How much tuna is it safe to eat?

Josh warns that eating more than about one tin of tuna a week is not great because of mercury. He mentions Jeremy Piven, the actor who played Ari in Entourage, who reportedly got mercury poisoning years ago from eating too much sushi.

Answered around 6:05
Where are sardines found and where are they popular?

Sardines live in shallow coastal temperate and subtropical oceans all over the world. They are very popular in Europe, especially Portugal and Spain, where they appear on many tapas menus. Fresh sardines are available in many Asian countries, while in the United States and the West people usually buy them in tins.

Answered around 7:05
Key Quote

“You said try sardines.”

— Chuck, Sardines on a Bagel, at 1:32▶ listen at 1:32
Key Quote

“I have zero recollection of telling you to try sardines, and I find them difficult to eat because of the texture.”

— Josh, Sardines on a Bagel, at 1:49▶ listen at 1:49
Key Quote

“You did not mention any of that when you told me to try sardines.”

— Chuck, Sardines on a Bagel, at 1:59▶ listen at 1:59
Key Quote

“I guess because they're tiny little fish looking at you.”

— Chuck, Sardines on a Bagel, at 2:51▶ listen at 2:51
Key Quote

“They don't grind it up like tuna or salmon or anything like that.”

— Josh, Sardines on a Bagel, at 2:57▶ listen at 2:57
Key Quote

“They're high in omega-3s, but they're low in saturated fats.”

— Josh, Sardines on a Bagel, at 11:52▶ listen at 11:52

Cite this

“Sardines on a Bagel.” https://27083.mc.tritondigital.com:443/OMNY_STUFFYOUSHOULDKNOW1_PODCAST_P/media-session/2dc3ac2b-7999-4221-b4de-f626b023750a/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/a91018a4-ea4f-4130-bf55-ae270180c327/311c0e00-9214-4172-a1b2-b486012d24c0/audio/direct/t1784710872/Short_Stuff_Sardines!.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/sardines-on-a-bagel.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?