Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World

1:18:14 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello and Nels Elde discuss a paper titled "a small polymerase ribozyme that can synthesize itself in its complementary strand," from the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge, first author Eduardo Gianni and senior author Philip Holiger.8:58
  • The field was stuck because the smallest ribozyme previously known with polymerase activity and the ability to self-replicate was 150 nucleotides, long enough that both random assembly and the folding of big RNAs work against it.21:55
  • The breakthrough was running the chemistry in eutectic ice, cold salty water forming ice crystals, which took the ribozyme from that 150-base version down to roughly 40 bases.31:26
  • After mutagenizing three motifs pulled from a pool of six trillion semi-randomized RNAs and seven more rounds of directed evolution, they arrived at QT51 and then truncated it to QT45, which polymerizes RNA triplets in cis and in trans.34:06
  • Self-replication of both plus and minus strands did work in one pot, but at a 0.25% yield over 72 days, and still with the experimenters tweaking pH and freeze-thaw conditions.46:22

Brief overview

A 45-letter ribozyme evolved in ice copies RNA templates and itself, making an RNA world plausible.

  1. Ice, not lipids, concentrated the chemistryEutectic ice channels hold the salty, concentrated conditions that people had assumed needed vesicles or membranes.
  2. Small enough to be findable by chanceAt 45 letters the odds are about 1 in 100 quadrillion, which billions of years of RNA make plausible.
  3. Slow, sloppy and barely working is the pointOne bond every quarter second, 72 days, under 1% yield, and piles of dead-end side products.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Who did this work and what is the paper called?

The paper is titled "A small polymerase ribozyme that can synthesize itself in its complementary strand." It comes from the MRC, the Medical Research Council Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge, UK. The first author is Eduardo Gianni and the senior author is Philip Holiger, with the whole group running the work at the MRC.

Answered around 8:58
What does the RNA world hypothesis propose?

It posits that you do not need DNA as the storage molecule or proteins as the enzymes: RNA, the ribozyme, can do both as a hybrid molecule. That opens up a simpler path, where chemicals bonded together start to form things that have the hallmarks of life and can work through genetics.

Answered around 20:10
Why were earlier polymerase ribozymes considered too big to arise naturally?

The smallest one known with polymerase activity and the ability to self-replicate was 150 nucleotides, 150 letters. Getting 150 together by chance with inefficient systems is improbable, and as RNA polymers get bigger they fold up on themselves into secondary structure, which makes them less accessible even though that folding is what gives enzyme activity.

Answered around 21:55
Why does running the chemistry in eutectic ice matter?

Eutectic ice is just cold salt water forming ice crystals. In ice the chemistry works better: the environment is organized so nucleotides come together and phosphodiester bonds form, which is less probable at room temperature. That was probably critical in going from the 150-base ribozyme to a 40-base one, and four billion years ago there was plenty of eutectic ice.

Answered around 31:08
Which ribozyme did they settle on, and what does its name mean?

They settle on QT45 as their top ribozyme. QT is short for quite tiny. They first came up with QT51, 51 letters folded in half into a stem loop, then noticed they could truncate it, taking away six of those letters to give QT45, which is pretty much just as active.

Answered around 37:54
Does the ribozyme actually copy itself?

Not literally. In actuality the molecule is not copying itself, it just copies something that looks like itself. It all happens at the population level with lots of these: conditions leave some unfolded and vulnerable to serving as a template, while some percentage stay folded up so they can act as the enzymes.

Answered around 45:57
What yield and timescale does the self-replication reaction need?

The yield is 0.25 percent and the time is slow: 72 days, more than two months, to get a yield of less than one percent from the reaction. The hosts call that persistence incredible, saying they would have stopped after a day and decided it does not work.

Answered around 46:22
How fast is this ribozyme as an enzyme?

It forms roughly one phosphodiester bond every quarter of a second, which is not even close by enzymology standards. For comparison, DNA polymerization for genome replication has three billion bases to copy for a cell division, and one bond every quarter second is nowhere near fast enough.

Answered around 32:48
What are the odds of a 45-letter ribozyme appearing in a random pool?

Something like 1 in 100 quadrillion, while their starting pool held only six trillion pieces of RNA, so they reached it by directed evolution rather than luck. But over a billion years or longer, with a lot of RNA around, it starts to approach plausibility on geologic timescales.

Answered around 38:49
How does directed evolution differ from experimental evolution?

In experimental evolution you take something like a virus, put it in a new environment such as an unfamiliar host cell, let it replicate again and again, and select for better replication. In directed evolution the selection is imposed by the experimenter: pools of RNA fragments are screened for the wanted activity, the active pool kept, and the round run again.

Answered around 23:24
Key Quote

“QT, short for quite tiny.”

— Nels Elde, Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World, at 34:17▶ listen at 34:17
Key Quote

“The patience to do this is just incredible.”

— Nels Elde, Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World, at 37:31▶ listen at 37:31
Key Quote

“Not only can this thing do the chemistry you need to, but can it produce more of itself?”

— Nels Elde, Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World, at 43:37▶ listen at 43:37
Key Quote

“That's the beauty of a cell is that everything is concentrated.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World, at 1:02:57▶ listen at 1:02:57

Cite this

“Self-Replicating Ribozyme and the RNA World.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO124.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/self-replicating-ribozyme-and-the-rna-world.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?