Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Selfish Genes in Nematodes

1:15:20 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello and Nels Elde open Twevo episode 122 with a paper from Alejandro Berga's group at the Institute of Molecular Biotechnology of the Austrian Academy of Sciences in Vienna, first author Polina Tikhanova, titled Recurrent Evolution of Selfishness from an Essential tRNA Synthetase in the nematode C. tropicalis, whose first sentence reads 'No genome on Earth is free of selfish genes.'16:37
  • Nels lays out the paper's two ideas: pre-suppression, where the antidote exists first and creates room for a toxin to emerge already neutralised and linked to it, and constructive neutral evolution, where complexity accumulates through random mutation without natural selection driving it.27:13
  • The toxins Puzzle 1 (PZL1) and Klimt 1 match a phenylalanine tRNA synthetase subunit in AlphaFold, while the antidotes KSS1 and KSS2 are F-box proteins at 50% sequence identity resembling Skp1-family E3 ubiquitin ligases, and AlphaFold Multimer, co-immunoprecipitation with mass spec and a GFP-tagged toxin all support the antidote tagging the toxin for degradation by the proteasome.37:00
  • Comparing about a dozen related species the authors find some 600 copies of these gene families with signatures of rapid evolution, infer that Puzzle 1 and KSS2 were the founding pair with Klimt 1 and Hyde 1 arriving later, and Nels ties this to his own lab's newly described E3 ubiquitin ligases that block flaviviruses and sit next to selfish elements in an iguana genome.49:14
  • For picks, Nels recommends JP Flores' podcast From Where Does It STEM and his co-founding of Stand Up for Science, and Vincent recommends Ross Anderson's Atlantic article An Act of Cosmic Sabotage on Trump calling for 40 of NASA's 124 science missions, including Mars sample return, to be defunded.1:03:20

Brief overview

Selfish toxin-antidote genes in C. tropicalis arose from duplicated tRNA synthetases pre-suppressed by ubiquitin ligase antidotes.

  1. The antidote comes first, then the toxin is toleratedPre-suppression explains how a toxin gene can arise without crashing its own lineage before an antidote exists.
  2. Antidotes are E3 ubiquitin ligases that degrade the toxinKSS proteins ubiquitinate Puzzle 1 and Klimt 1 for the proteasome, a mechanism Nels had not seen in toxin-antidote systems before.
  3. Selfish elements may seed antiviral genesNels' lab found flavivirus-blocking E3 ligases next to selfish elements in reptile genomes, suggesting antidotes can be repurposed against viruses.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What makes a toxin-antidote system a selfish genetic element?

A genome encodes a poison the mother passes into the egg, linked to an antidote. Offspring carrying both are protected, while those that lose the linkage are killed by the toxin. Because of this, the linked pair becomes over-represented in the population, going beyond the normal rules of inheritance and promoting its own propagation.

Answered around 19:32
How can a toxin evolve without killing its host before an antidote exists?

The authors pick up the idea of pre-suppression: the antidote evolves first, with some other function, creating biological space for a toxin to emerge already suppressed. If the new toxin is linked to that pre-existing antidote, selfishness unfolds; copies where the two become disconnected are killed and lost from the record.

Answered around 27:13
What kind of protein are the Puzzle 1 and Klimt 1 toxins related to?

Using AlphaFold and related machine-learning structure predictions, both toxins, Puzzle 1 and Klimt 1, overlap structurally with a tRNA synthetase subunit for phenylalanine. tRNA synthetases are the essential enzymes that couple amino acids to tRNAs for protein translation. A third system, Hyde 1, is named for harmful phenylalanine tRNA synthetase duplicate.

Answered around 37:00
How do the KSS (KISS) antidotes neutralize the toxins?

Sequence comparison at about 50% identity identified them as F-box proteins, and structural modeling showed similarity to E3 ubiquitin ligases of the SKP1 family. The proposal is that the antidote recognizes the toxin and tags it with ubiquitin, targeting it to the proteasome for degradation, a mechanism the hosts had never heard of for an antidote.

Answered around 40:04
What experimental evidence supports degradation of the toxin by the antidote?

AlphaFold Multimer predicted the antidotes interact with Puzzle 1 and Klimt 1, pull-downs and co-immunoprecipitation showed biochemical interaction, and in-worm mass spec with the KSS antidote as bait recovered other E3 ligase components. A GFP-tagged, non-toxic Puzzle 1 dropped in fluorescence when the antidote was added back, consistent with degradation.

Answered around 45:11
What happens to embryos that get the toxin but not the antidote?

The paper does not explain the molecular mechanism of the poison, but describes the outcome. Fertilized eggs start developing into embryos or larvae, then fail. With Puzzle 1 the embryos become really bloated, and with Klimt 1 they become shriveled up at one stage, without the KSS or KISS antidotes.

Answered around 39:01
How were these toxin-antidote systems discovered in C. tropicalis?

Researchers collect nematode worms from soil and compost heaps, cross strains of the same species, and count F1 and F2 progeny to find incompatible combinations. Long-read sequencing mapped candidate regions, and CRISPR knockouts confirmed the genes: removing the toxin restores Mendelian ratios, while removing the antidote exposes inviable offspring.

Answered around 32:19
How widespread are these genes across related worm species?

Looking at about a dozen close relatives of C. tropicalis, they find around 600 copies of these toxin and antidote genes, with the Klimt family reaching 600 and the KSS family in the hundreds, plus signatures of rapid evolution. Puzzle 1 and KISS 2 appear in all species, so they are inferred to be the founding pair.

Answered around 49:14
What is constructive neutral evolution and how does it apply here?

It is the idea that complexity emerges from random mutation without natural selection acting on it; when contingencies come together, a system simply works. The hosts note that the evidence in the paper can be explained by messy, random, neutral processes, a roll of the dice, rather than a system trying to achieve something.

Answered around 29:33
How does this paper connect to Nels Elde's own lab research?

His lab recently described a family of E3 ubiquitin ligases, first found in an iguana genome, that are potent antivirals against flaviviruses like dengue and yellow fever. These TRIM-type ligases sit right next to selfish genetic elements, suggesting antidotes might later evolve, through a few mutational steps, to recognize virus capsids.

Answered around 43:21
Key Quote

“No genome on Earth is free of selfish genes.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Selfish Genes in Nematodes, at 18:19▶ listen at 18:19
Key Quote

“Plenty of confidence and very little competence.”

— Nels Elde, Selfish Genes in Nematodes, at 13:48▶ listen at 13:48
Key Quote

“Choosing the right organism for one's research is as important as finding the right problems to work on.”

— Nels Elde, Selfish Genes in Nematodes, at 25:22▶ listen at 25:22
Key Quote

“Yeah, evolution doesn't give up.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Selfish Genes in Nematodes, at 55:01▶ listen at 55:01

Cite this

“Selfish Genes in Nematodes.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO122.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/selfish-genes-in-nematodes.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?