SEO success requires gap analysis across technical, content, and link pillars to identify where your site underperforms versus competitors—not in isolation, but within the live search ecosystem.
The three pillars are technical SEO, content, and links. Technical SEO enables search engines to find and understand content and users to enjoy it; links signal trust and endorsement to Google; and content satisfies user intent, making it the central pillar.
A search competitor is someone targeting the same audience, ranking for or targeting the same keywords, and whose product would make yours obsolete — meaning if the target audience chooses their product, they no longer need yours.
The top-down approach (fast, best for established sites) uses internal team input and competitive tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs. The bottom-up approach (more precise, best for new or low-visibility sites) identifies competitors by analyzing top 10 SERP domains for core keywords and clustering by topic.
She measured number of keywords ranking in the top 30, count of editorial URLs (256), estimated traffic split between editorial, branded, and product pages, and editorial URL efficiency — finding strong efficiency but too few URLs, prompting a content creation focus.
She compared branded vs. unbranded traffic, backlinks, referring domains, domain authority, branded search volume, and link growth over 3–12 months. She found Sanity below average in branded traffic and backlinks despite decent branded search volume, indicating a lack of matching branded content.
She analyzes Core Web Vitals (LCP, FID, CLS) using the free Chrome UX Report in Google Data Studio to calculate the percentage of 'good' URLs, averages it per site, and compares desktop and mobile page speed — prioritizing desktop for SaaS.
She prioritized content over brand because Sanity was below average in brand but she was new and needed stakeholder buy-in; content was both her strength and required less risk than immediate link-building, enabling faster execution and early wins.
At least every six months, preferably every three months for fast-moving industries like SaaS; slower-moving industries may do it yearly, but six months is a solid rule of thumb for most businesses.
Yes, but it shifts from 'gap analysis' to 'competitor research' — removing your domain from the template lets you reverse-engineer competitor priorities (e.g., Core Web Vitals thresholds, content depth) to inform your launch strategy instead of fixing gaps.
Create 'linkable assets' with linking intent — content like original stats, research, or frameworks that others naturally cite to validate claims. If such content ranks, it attracts passive, contextual links without manual outreach.
“SEO is a zero-sum game, which means that every position that you gain, someone is losing.”
“I propose that we went with content, which is also what I am best at in the three pillars of SEO, in my opinion.”
“Nothing slows you down more than having to redo the content because it wasn't what your stakeholder needed.”
“If you look at that template and you remove your name from it, it's just competitor research from an SEO perspective.”
“You could go out with a news checking approach... or creating assets with linking intent—content that people naturally reference to validate their own statements.”
“SEO Gap Analysis Framework.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bifcyYEUntk. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/seo-gap-analysis-framework.html.