SEO success comes from testing what works for your specific site and audience—not following generic 'best practices' or chasing algorithmic myths like EAT or schema as ranking factors.
James Dooley says he doesn't look at best practices at all—he just does what works through in-house testing, ignores public noise, and doesn't follow general SEO advice. David Quaid agrees, stating he doesn't listen to the 'general public' on SEO and instead relies on internal testing, noting that for certain sites they might use schema or other elements, but only when proven effective—not as dogma.
The site 'getyourtipsout.com' had an unnatural links penalty, ~4,500 404s, no topical authority, poor internal linking, and thin content (e.g., 'Monday's tips'), yet an article on it ranked #2 for 'best horse racing betting sites in the UK'—a £20,000/month keyword—because it appeared in Google News and attracted strong branded and social traffic.
No—they both reject that idea. David states E-A-T is not a ranking algorithm and calls it 'rubbish' as a universal factor; James adds that Google’s official SEO Starter Guide debunks E-A-T as a ranking signal. They agree it only applies narrowly to YMYL topics and is assessed by human raters—not algorithms—and that claiming expertise (e.g., via author bios) cannot be algorithmically verified.
They agree schema is not a general ranking factor: David says it's either 'absolutely required' (e.g., for job listings or Google Flights) or 'mostly niche', and James confirms 99% of his sites don’t use it. Both stress that stacking schema or treating it as a universal ranking booster is misguided—its value is functional (e.g., enabling rich results or disambiguation), not algorithmic.
They define SEO as 'relevance multiplied by authority'. Relevance comes from precise document naming (e.g., URL/title matching the query), while authority stems from backlinks, branded search volume, and click-through behavior—not abstract signals like E-A-T or schema. They emphasize that low-authority sites need hyper-specific pages (e.g., 'what is a ribeye' as its own page), whereas high-authority sites can host broader topics.
“I don't really listen to the general public of what we only deal with in-house testing.”
“It jumped in in position number two for best horse racing betting sites in the uk.”
“The EAT framework doesn't mention backlinks. It doesn't mention anything about return visits.”
“SEO is about relevance multiplied by authority.”
“You need a page, you need a title, you need some content, you need internal authority, and you need external authority. Ready, set, go.”
“SEO Myths and Best Practices Debunked.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jW8hYUn99Uk. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/seo-myths-and-best-practices-debunked.html.