Zoo records across mammals and birds show no single rule for which sex lives longer.
No. Among humans, women worldwide average about five years longer than men, and in the US the gap is around ten years. But the trend is known to reverse in many bird species, and also in amphibians and insects, so which sex lives longer depends on the species or group being compared.
Answered around 14:17Three ideas are discussed: harmful effects of being the heterogametic sex (XY males in mammals, ZW females in birds); sexual selection, such as costly antlers, plumage and sperm competition in males; and the cost of reproduction for females, including gestation, egg laying, offspring production and parental care. The hypotheses are not mutually exclusive.
Answered around 17:07From the Species360 Zoological Information Management System (ZIMS), based in Bloomington, Minnesota, where zoos share records on their animals. Previous studies had around a hundred mammals and a couple hundred birds; this one covers roughly 530 mammal and 650 bird species, spanning 20 of 29 mammalian orders and 31 of 42 bird orders.
Answered around 24:00Zoos largely remove predators, starvation and much of the mating competition, so the comparison focuses more on physiology. Sexual size dimorphism is also reduced in zoos. The hosts note this is simplified, since infections still spread in zoos, and the study also compared 69 mammal and 41 bird populations from the wild.
Answered around 24:58They measured adult life expectancy (ALE), the average age at death in a population, and converted male versus female ALE to a scale from minus one to one. Positive values mean a female advantage, so 0.5 means a 50% female advantage, and zero means both sexes live equally long.
Answered around 32:26Only partly. The authors say their results partially support the heterogametic sex hypothesis, but having different sex chromosomes alone cannot explain the breadth of variation in life expectancy. The hosts describe this as pouring cold water on the idea and pointing more toward environmental and other factors.
Answered around 41:28Carnivores show a male advantage in zoos, with wolves and wild dogs giving the strongest evidence; over 70% of canid species in zoos do not follow the expected female advantage. Eleven species showed no difference, and lemurs, though mostly non-monogamous, show no ALE difference between the sexes.
Answered around 44:17Among primates it ranges from about a 30% to a 33% female advantage depending on species. In hominids all sampled species show a female advantage, but it is less pronounced in humans than in chimpanzee and gorilla populations, and even smaller in South American monkeys such as howler monkeys.
Answered around 44:57The phylogenetic analysis points to pre-copulatory costs, like moose antlers or ram horns, as shortening male lifespans, especially in non-monogamous species. Female ALE advantage is greatest in non-monogamous species. When zoos remove that competitive pressure, male lifespans start to rise, while monogamous males face less competition for mates.
Answered around 37:34Yes. Female allocation to parental care was positively associated with females living longer in zoos, and the effect was even greater in wild populations. The hosts suggest this undercuts the idea that only reaching reproductive age matters, since parents and grandparents can add fitness through caring for relatives.
Answered around 55:20“Drive fast, take chances, encode a Y chromosome.”
“You can never, ever make conclusions from an observational study because you can't get rid of all the confounding variables.”
“So you can't just make a generalized statement.”
“There's no one mechanism that applies to all species for sure.”
“Sexual Selection & Sex Differences in Lifespan.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO119.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/sexual-selection-sex-differences-in-lifespan.html.