Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Sniffing Out Superbugs

55:38 recording · AUTO · 4 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Michael Schmidt presents an open-access perspective by Bilgin and colleagues from Zurich and Lucerne, Switzerland, titled Microbial and Antimicrobial Resistance Diagnostics by Gas Sensors and Machine Learning, which proposes identifying infections from the volatile organic compounds bacteria emit.3:25
  • He argues today's diagnostics still rest on methods Robert Koch pioneered at the Imperial Health Office in Berlin in 1880 — roughly 150 years — taking days to weeks and driving empiric broad-spectrum prescribing, while the WHO now demands faster tools.12:07
  • On cost, he notes MALDI-TOF identifies a microbe for about a nickel once instrument, labor and database subscription are set aside, but gas sensors built on chem-bio responsive materials could be cheap and portable enough for rural clinics and low- and middle-income regions.20:21
  • Michelle Swanson then covers an mBio paper from Beth Honor's lab at Cornell with Oregon State, Harmful Algal Bloom Species, Microcystis Originosa Releases Thiamin Antivitamins to Suppress Competitors.36:51
  • In co-culture the green algae Chlamydomonas population declined about 35% while the cyanobacterium rose about 23%, an inhibition traced to the antivitamin basamethrin and reversed by adding thiamine, with the same compound found rising during the August bloom in Upper Klamath Lake.40:08

Brief overview

Smelling bacterial volatiles could replace slow cultures, and an algal bloom species starves rivals with thiamine antivitamins.

  1. Volatiles could identify microbes in minutesThe proposed method reads volatile organics straight from a swab, stool, urine or blood sample, promising results in minutes or hours instead of days to weeks.
  2. The database is the hard partGrowth medium, humidity and nutrient availability all shift the volatile profile, so the reference library must be as robust as a drug-sniffing dog's trained brain.
  3. Microcystis starves competitors of vitamin B1Basamethrin, known for more than 60 years, gums up the thiamine pathway of green algae, and it was detected in lake water during the bloom season.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How can bacterial infections be diagnosed by smell?

Bilgin and colleagues propose analyzing the volatilome, the volatile organic compounds bacteria spew out during normal metabolism: ammonia from protein degradation, acetaldehyde and ethanol from anaerobic sugar fermentation, indole from E. coli, 2-aminoacetophenone from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. No single VOC identifies a microbe, but their relative concentrations discriminate species with reasonable certainty.

Answered around 5:13
Why are today's microbiology diagnostics considered slow and outdated?

Present-day methods were pioneered by Robert Koch at the Imperial Health Office in Berlin in 1880, roughly 150 years ago. Tried and true, but slow and expensive, they push clinicians toward empiric broad-spectrum antibiotics that fuel selective pressure. Definitive answers take days, sometimes weeks, while patients suffer and resistance spreads.

Answered around 12:07
How much faster would the volatile method be than culture?

Current culture methods take days to weeks to identify a pathogen, and the organism must then be grown again to assess antibiotic susceptibility, which drives empiric prescribing. The proposed method promises results within minutes or hours by directly analyzing the volatile organics emitted by bacteria in the patient's sample, without separating it into constituent microbes.

Answered around 16:34
Can volatile compounds distinguish resistant bacteria from susceptible ones?

The authors report that extended-spectrum beta-lactamase producing and non-producing E. coli can be separated by a combination of differentially expressed VOCs with high specificity and, more importantly, high sensitivity, avoiding false negatives and positives. E. coli sequence type 131, which commonly carries those beta-lactamases, has reportedly been smelled in the literature.

Answered around 17:54
What can volatile sensing detect that culture cannot?

Viable but non-culturable bacteria. When a polymicrobial infection meets an antimicrobial that induces a sufficient oxidative state, some microbes go dormant: the drugs do not work and the lab cannot culture them, so it assumes they are absent. They still annoy the immune system and drive pathology, and volatiles reveal their baseline metabolism.

Answered around 25:59
What does identifying one microbe cost with current technology?

Factoring out labor, the instrument and the chromatogram subscription, identifying a microbe by MALDI-TOF costs a nickel, five cents. The authors instead offer molecular gas sensors based on chem-bio responsive metals and materials as the core technology for cheaper, faster tests, much as nanopore sequencing drove down the cost of sequencing.

Answered around 20:21
What causes harmful algal blooms and why are they dangerous?

Algae are microscopic photosynthetic organisms living naturally in fresh and salt water. They bloom, outcompeting other creatures, when temperatures rise or nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus increase through runoff from fertilized fields or sewage. Blooms consume oxygen, endangering plants and fish, and some, like Microcystis aeruginosa in the Great Lakes, make toxins causing GI and liver disease.

Answered around 37:36
What happens when green algae and the cyanobacterium are grown together?

In co-culture the green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii population declined by about 35%, whereas the cyanobacterium population increased about 23%. The literature suggested Microcystis starves the green algae for thiamine, better known as vitamin B1, and a simple addition of extra thiamine to the medium let the green algae keep growing.

Answered around 40:08
Which compound does Microcystis release to suppress its competitors?

Basamethrin, an antivitamin first observed more than 60 years ago and also made by clostridium and some streptomyces. It acts as a substrate for the enzymes that generate thiamine, gumming up the pathway so the target organism starves for vitamin B1. A second compound, methyl oxothiochrome, had similar effects, both relieved by thiamine.

Answered around 44:19
Does this antivitamin actually appear in real lakes?

Collaborating with a group from Oregon State, they sampled Upper Klamath Lake in southwest Oregon, from the north and south sides, in May before any blooms and in August at the peak of bloom season. Biochemical analysis showed basamethrin production increased significantly during the bloom, the first documentation of its release in fresh waters.

Answered around 47:51
Key Quote

“Forget your fancy PCR machines and your week-long culture plates,”

— Michael Schmidt, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 5:03▶ listen at 5:03
Key Quote

“Is that a technical term, Michael, zit?”

— Vincent Racaniello, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 6:27▶ listen at 6:27
Key Quote

“Zit is definitely a technical term coined by many, many learned physicians.”

— Michael Schmidt, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 6:29▶ listen at 6:29
Key Quote

“We just sniff the sample.”

— Michael Schmidt, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 16:58▶ listen at 16:58
Key Quote

“We're so lucky to have the World Health Organization leading this initiative.”

— Michael Schmidt, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 31:26▶ listen at 31:26
Key Quote

“Competition for nutrients. Don't I know a lot about that? I grew up in a family of six kids.”

— Michelle Swanson, Sniffing Out Superbugs, at 53:57▶ listen at 53:57

Cite this

“Sniffing Out Superbugs.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twimshow/TWiM336.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/sniffing-out-superbugs.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?