Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Solitude and Self-Reliance

23:26 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Executive Summary AI
  • The narrator refuses to let anyone copy his mode of living, urging instead that each person carefully find and pursue his own way, not his father's or his neighbor's.
  • He defines real cooperation as getting our living together, and illustrates its rarity with two young men proposing to travel the world, one earning his way, the other carrying a bill of exchange, who would part at the first crisis.
  • Confessing he has indulged very little in philanthropic enterprises, he says that when he offered to maintain certain poor persons as comfortably as himself, they one and all unhesitatingly preferred to remain poor.
  • He recounts pitying the ragged Irish labourers cutting ice on the pond until one who fell in stripped off three pairs of pants and two pairs of stockings at his house, after which he concluded it would be a greater charity to give himself a flannel shirt than a whole slop-shop to the labourer.
  • He closes by attacking the cant that ranks Penn, Howard, and Mrs. Fry above Shakespeare, Bacon, Cromwell, Milton, and Newton, demanding justice for all whose lives and works bless mankind, and quoting Sheikh Sadi's Gulistan on the cypress, called azad or free because it bears no fruit.

Brief overview

Thoreau argues each man should follow his own calling rather than professional philanthropy, which he judges overrated.

  1. Pursue your own way, not an inherited oneHe would have each one be very careful to find out and pursue his own way, and not his father's or his mother's or his neighbor's instead.
  2. Cooperation means getting our living togetherThe only cooperation commonly possible is partial and superficial; the man who goes alone can start today, while he who travels with another must wait.
  3. Strike at the root, not the branches of evilA thousand hack at the branches of evil to one who strikes at the root, and the biggest giver may be producing the misery he tries to relieve.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Should I copy someone else's way of living?

He would not have anyone adopt his mode of living on any account, because he desires as many different persons in the world as possible. Each one should be very careful to find out and pursue his own way, not his father's or mother's or neighbor's. The youth may build or plant or sail, only let him not be hindered.

Is it cheaper to share walls with a neighbor or build alone?

A large house is not proportionally more expensive than a small one, since one roof may cover, one cellar underlie and one wall separate several apartments. Still he preferred the solitary dwelling: it is commonly cheaper to build the whole yourself than to convince another of the advantage of the common wall, which must then be thin.

Why could the two young men travelling the world not cooperate?

One was to travel without money, earning his means as he went, before the mast and behind the plough; the other carried a bill of exchange in his pocket. Since one would not operate at all, they could not long be companions, and would part at the first interesting crisis in their adventures.

What happened when he offered to support poor townspeople?

There were those who used all their arts to persuade him to undertake the support of some poor family in the town. When he thought to indulge himself, maintaining certain poor persons in all respects as comfortably as he maintains himself, and even ventured so far as to make them the offer, they one and all unhesitatingly preferred to remain poor.

What did the Irish labourer who fell in the pond teach him?

He used to pity the clumsy Irish labourers cutting ice on the pond in mean and ragged clothes, while he shivered in tidier, more fashionable garments. Then one who slipped into the water came to warm himself and stripped off three pairs of pants and two pairs of stockings; he could refuse the extra garments offered.

How should you actually give aid to the poor?

Give the poor the aid they most need, though it be your example which leaves them far behind. If you give money, spend yourself with it, and do not merely abandon it to them. Often the poor man is not so cold and hungry as dirty and ragged; given money he will perhaps buy more rags.

Why does he say philanthropy is overrated?

Philanthropy is almost the only virtue sufficiently appreciated by mankind, and it is greatly overrated; it is our selfishness which overrates it. A robust poor man in Concord praised a fellow townsman for being kind to the poor, meaning himself. The kind uncles and aunts of the race are more esteemed than its true spiritual fathers and mothers.

Who did the lecturer call England's greatest, and why object?

A reverend lecturer enumerated England's scientific, literary and political worthies — Shakespeare, Bacon, Cromwell, Milton, Newton and others — then spoke of her Christian heroes, Penn, Howard and Mrs. Fry, elevating them far above all the rest. Everyone must feel the falsehood and cant of this: they were only, perhaps, her best philanthropists.

What happened to Phaeton when he drove the sun's chariot?

Wishing to prove his heavenly birth by his beneficence, Phaeton had the sun's chariot but one day and drove out of the beaten track. He burned several blocks of houses in the lower streets of heaven, scorched the earth, dried up every spring and made the Sahara, till Jupiter hurled him down with a thunderbolt.

Why is the fruitless cypress the only tree called free?

In the Gulistan of Sheikh Sadi of Shiraz, a wise man explains that every other tree has its appropriate produce and season, fresh and blooming then dry and withered; the cypress is exposed to neither state, being always flourishing. If thy hand has plenty be liberal as the date-tree, otherwise be an Azad, free like the cypress.

Key Quote

“If a man has faith, he will cooperate with equal faith everywhere.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 2:43▶ listen at 2:43
Key Quote

“To cooperate in the highest as well as the lowest sense means to get our living together.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 2:56▶ listen at 2:56
Key Quote

“There is no odor so bad as that which arises from goodness tainted. It is human, it is divine carrion.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 8:15▶ listen at 8:15
Key Quote

“I can find you a Newfoundland dog that will do as much.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 9:14▶ listen at 9:14
Key Quote

“This is a charity that hides a multitude of sins.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 15:30▶ listen at 15:30
Key Quote

“We should impart our courage, and not our despair, our health and ease, and not our disease, and take care that this does not spread by contagion.”

— Solitude and Self-Reliance, at 15:47▶ listen at 15:47

Cite this

“Solitude and Self-Reliance.” https://www.archive.org/download/walden_librivox/walden_c01_p05_64kb.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/solitude-and-self-reliance.html.

Transcript

0:00 CHAPTER I. ECONOMY
0:27 One young man of my acquaintance, who has inherited some acres, told me that he thought
0:38 he should live as I did, if he had the means.
0:41 I would not have anyone adopt my mode of living on any account. For, beside that before
0:47 he has fairly learned it I may have found out another for myself, I desire that there may be
0:53 as many different persons in the world as possible. But I would have each one be very careful to find
1:00 out and pursue his own way, and not his father's or his mother's or his neighbor's instead.
1:07 The youth may build or plant or sail.
1:13 Only let him not be hindered from doing that which he tells me he would like to do.
1:19 It is by a mathematical point only that we are wise, as the sailor or the fugitive slave keeps the pole star
1:27 in his eye, but that is sufficient guidance for all our life. We may not arrive at our port
1:36 within a calculable period, but we would preserve the true course.
1:43 Undoubtedly, in this case, what is true for one is truer still for a thousand as a large house is not proportionally more expensive than a small one since one roof may cover one cellar underlie and one wall separate several apartments but for my part i preferred the solitary dwelling moreover it will commonly be cheaper to build the whole yourself than to convince another of the advantage of the common wall
2:13 and when you have done this the common partition to be much cheaper must be a thin one and that other may prove a bad neighbor, and also not keep his side in repair.
2:27 The only cooperation which is commonly possible is exceedingly partial and superficial,
2:33 and what little true cooperation there is, is as if it were not being a harmony inaudible to men.
2:43 If a man has faith, he will cooperate with equal faith everywhere.
2:49 If he has not faith, he will continue to live like the rest of the world, whatever company he is joined to.
2:56 To cooperate in the highest as well as the lowest sense means to get our living together.
3:08 I heard it proposed lately that two young men should travel together over the world, the one without money, earning his means as he went,
3:14 before the mast and behind the plough, the other carrying a bill of exchange in his pocket.
3:20 It was easy to see that they could not long be companions or co-operate since one would not operate at all they would part at the first interesting crisis in their adventures
3:33 above all as i have implied the man who goes alone can start to-day but he who travels with another must wait till that other is ready, and it may be a long time before
3:46 they get off. But all this is very selfish, I have heard some of my townsmen say. I confess
3:54 that I have hitherto indulged very little in philanthropic enterprises. I have made some
4:00 sacrifices to a sense of duty, and among others have sacrificed this pleasure also, there are
4:07 those who have used all their arts to persuade me to undertake the support of some poor family in
4:13 the town, and if I had nothing to do, for the devil finds employment for the idle, I might try
4:20 my hand at some such pastime as that. However, when I have thought to indulge myself in this respect,
4:29 and lay their heaven under an obligation by maintaining certain poor persons in all respects
4:35 as comfortably as I maintain myself, and have even ventured so far as to make them the offer, they have one and all unhesitatingly preferred to remain poor.
4:48 While my town's men and women are devoted in so many ways to the good of their fellows,
4:54 I trust that one at least may be spared two other and less humane pursuits.
5:02 You must have a genius for charity, as well as for anything else. As for doing good,
5:10 that is one of the professions which are full. Moreover, I have tried it fairly,
5:17 and, strange as it may seem, am satisfied that it does not agree with my constitution.
5:24 Probably I should not consciously and deliberately
5:26 forsake my particular calling to do the good which society demands of me, to save the universe
5:34 from annihilation. And I believe that a like but infinitely greater steadfastness elsewhere
5:42 is all that now preserves it. But I would not stand between any man and his

Showing the first 40 of 184 lines.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?