Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Spring Weather and Virus Research

1:55:45 recording · AUTO · 3 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • A KFF Health News item reports that U.S. scientists have now released 1,000 measles genomes after only eight had come out of the epidemic, the delay attributed to the fact that the sequences will show continuous domestic spread and cost the country its elimination certification.8:18
  • A New York Times piece by Aparva Mandavilli says acting CDC director Jay Bhattacharya delayed an MMWR paper on COVID vaccine effectiveness to review its observational statistical methods, which the hosts call unprecedented meddling by a director who should never touch a specific paper.10:51
  • The Neurology paper from Paul Schultz's team at UT Health in Houston and Massachusetts General asked whether high-dose flu vaccine, 60 micrograms of hemagglutinin against the standard 15, changes three-year Alzheimer's risk in people 65 and older, emulating a trial inside the IQVIA claims database that starts at 28 million people and winnows to 185,000 high-dose and 54,000 standard-dose records.29:21
  • Cumulative Alzheimer's risk was significantly lower with the high dose from months 1 to 25 per protocol and 1 to 28 in the intention-to-treat design, a number needed to treat of 185 and 270 and roughly a 22% risk reduction, stronger in women, with the protection fading by months 29 to 35 and so arguing for a shot every year.39:26
  • In Cell, Joe McKellar and senior author Karim Majoub showed animal delta viruses get packaged whole inside VSV, herpes simplex and snake arenavirus particles rather than merely borrowing their glycoproteins, and in the natural boa constrictor system those particles were 2,000-fold more infectious than free delta virions.54:17

Brief overview

TWiV 1313: high-dose flu vaccine lowers Alzheimer's risk, and delta viruses stow away inside helper virions.

  1. High-dose flu shot cut three-year Alzheimer's riskNumber needed to treat was 185 per protocol and 270 intention-to-treat, about a 22% reduction, stronger in women than men.
  2. Delta viruses hitch a ride inside helper virionsCryo-EM, super-resolution and immunogold imaging put whole delta particles inside VSV, HSV and Gießen virus virions, and only the packaged ones infected cells.
  3. CDC leadership is filtering the scienceBhattacharya held an MMWR vaccine-effectiveness paper and 1,000 measles genomes sat unreleased; the hosts trust the remaining scientists but not the leadership.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Does the high-dose flu shot lower Alzheimer's risk more than the standard dose?

Compared with the standard influenza vaccine, cumulative Alzheimer's risk was significantly lower after the high dose from months 1 to 25 in the per-protocol design and 1 to 28 in the intention-to-treat design. The maximum significant risk difference was 0.0054, a risk reduction of about 22 percent.

Answered around 39:26
How many people need the high dose to prevent one Alzheimer's case?

The number needed to treat is 185 people in the per-protocol design and 270 in the intention-to-treat design. The intention-to-treat figure covers the whole population, including people who never got vaccinated, so the effect is diluted a bit. Vincent found the risk reduction stated as about 22 percent.

Answered around 39:54
What is actually different about the high-dose flu vaccine?

The regular dose has 15 micrograms of hemagglutinin; the high dose has four times that, 60 micrograms, and is only for people 65 and up. Seroconversion gives about 25 percent higher HAI titers, and it is 24 percent more efficacious against severe disease, with more injection-site pain.

Answered around 29:36
Do women and men benefit equally from the vaccine's dementia effect?

Women benefited more than men. Both showed lower Alzheimer's risk with high versus standard dose, but the duration and strength were greater in women; for men the per-protocol result was not statistically significant, although the intention-to-treat result was. Men still gain protection against flu hospitalisation.

Answered around 41:19
How do delta viruses spread if they cannot make their own capsid?

They get packaged inside helper virus particles. Beyond stealing glycoproteins from the helper, a delta virion can ride within the particle itself, which the authors call a Trojan horse. They also seem not to be picky, apparently able to hitch a ride with several different viruses.

Answered around 54:17
Can delta virus infect cells without riding inside a herpes particle?

No. Supernatants holding free delta particles could not initiate infection, while the pellet containing herpes simplex virions with delta inside could. Herpes glycoproteins alone, or cytomegalovirus glycoproteins, never produced particles that worked. So for herpes simplex there is a mandatory reliance on the stealth mechanism.

Answered around 1:16:11
Does this packaging happen in a natural virus and host pairing?

Yes, in snakes. Boa constrictor kidney cells making snake delta virus were infected with University of Gießen virus 1, a reptarenavirus. Roughly 12 to 20 percent of particles carried an extra internal density, and those virions were 2,000-fold more infectious than free delta particles.

Answered around 1:23:01
Why compare two vaccine doses instead of vaccinated against unvaccinated people?

Comparing vaccinated with unvaccinated introduces bias: people who get their flu shot tend to live healthier lives and have better socioeconomic status. Comparing standard dose with high dose means everyone got a shot, so only dosage differs, and many patients may not even have chosen their dose.

Answered around 31:49
What data did the Alzheimer's study rely on, and how many people?

IQVIA Pharmetrics Plus for Academics, a US commercial claims database with inpatient, outpatient and pharmacy claims from all 50 states, covering January 2014 through September 2022. They started from 28 million people and whittled it down to 185,000 high-dose and 54,000 standard-dose records.

Answered around 32:29
Why does releasing a thousand measles genomes matter?

Only eight genomes had been released from the US epidemic until now. Genomes show where the virus comes from and whether it moves between states, Texas to North Carolina to Utah. Continuous spread means endemic circulation, which means the US certification of elimination is gone.

Answered around 8:28
Key Quote

“There shouldn't be a thousand measles genomes to sequence.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Spring Weather and Virus Research, at 9:57▶ listen at 9:57
Key Quote

“immortal time bias, which is not people turning into vampires.”

— Alan Dove, Spring Weather and Virus Research, at 38:00▶ listen at 38:00
Key Quote

“So we call that the hitchhiker syndrome.”

— Rich Condit, Spring Weather and Virus Research, at 1:11:16▶ listen at 1:11:16
Key Quote

“So basically the finding here is that delta viruses, animal delta viruses, can be packaged within helper virus particles, which is something we didn't know.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Spring Weather and Virus Research, at 1:24:03▶ listen at 1:24:03

Cite this

“Spring Weather and Virus Research.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twiv/TWiV1313.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/spring-weather-and-virus-research.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?