Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy

41:18 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello and Daniel Griffin open TWiV episode 1300, recorded February 26, 2026, and frame the show around the quotation "There are lies, damn lies, and statistics," which Samuel Clemens attributed to Benjamin Disraeli.0:10
  • They cover states suing the federal government over childhood vaccine schedule changes and attack the Surgeon General nomination of Casey Means, who finished medical school in 2013, dropped out of ENT training, sells wellness products through her company Levels, told Bill Cassidy the hepatitis B birth dose was "very complex" without answering, and refused to say she would encourage vaccination.2:58
  • Daniel reads from a CID article on circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus type 2 in Pakistan: 35,724 paralytic cases and 2,804 sewage samples tested between July 2019 and March 2022, cVDPV2 in 0.5% (181 cases) and 11% of sewage, with 14 monovalent OPV2 rounds and five IPV rounds between September 2019 and December 2021 interrupting transmission in about two years, and Vincent calls the 2016 trival8:32
  • On the respiratory season they report 979 confirmed measles cases (CDC says 982, Johns Hopkins over a thousand) with hotspots in Utah, Arizona and Florida, flu plateauing but growing across the Ohio River Valley with 71 confirmed pediatric deaths, RSV rising in most states, and COVID going up nationally, very high in the Midwest.15:19
  • Daniel walks through the Inter-COVID Consortium preeclampsia study in eClinical Medicine — 6,527 pregnant women from 18 countries, 2020 to 2022, 33% diagnosed with COVID-19 — where COVID raised preeclampsia about 45%, the unvaccinated had an adjusted odds ratio of 1.78, any vaccination cut risk about 15%, a booster 0.67 or about 33%, and 58% in women with preexisting morbidities, then answers list21:19

Brief overview

Lies from health officials collide with hard data on polio, measles, flu and pregnancy vaccination.

  1. IPV, not OPV, ends vaccine-derived polioNot a single paralytic case was diagnosed after IPV administration in Pakistan, and Vincent says WHO should stop seeding the environment with OPV.
  2. Vaccination in pregnancy is the safer choiceVaccinated women had lower preeclampsia, less maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality, and less preterm birth, plus passive protection for the baby.
  3. Unqualified nominees still carry the Surgeon General's pulpitCasey Means dodged Cassidy's hepatitis B question and refused to endorse vaccination, yet people will respect a position once held by qualified people.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Does COVID-19 vaccination during pregnancy change preeclampsia risk?

In the INTERCOVID cohort of 6,527 pregnant women from 18 countries, COVID-19 raised preeclampsia about 45%, and about 78% in unvaccinated women. Any vaccination cut the risk roughly 15%, a booster about 33%, and 58% in women with pre-existing morbidities, with less maternal and perinatal morbidity and preterm birth.

Answered around 23:09
When during pregnancy should flu, COVID and RSV vaccines be given?

Get the flu and COVID shots before pregnancy so you are protected yourself. Then vaccinate right at the beginning of the third trimester, for RSV, COVID and flu, giving time for a robust response that passes antibodies and also a cellular component on to the baby.

Answered around 29:48
Do vaccines in pregnancy raise autism risk the way infections do?

Maternal immune activation is real, but Daniel stresses these are immune system challenges resulting from infections, not vaccinations. The increase in autism spectrum conditions is estimated at about 15%, thereabouts, depending on how serious the infection is, particularly in the first trimester. Vaccination is what avoids that infection.

Answered around 28:58
Should adults over 60 get the hepatitis B vaccine?

Daniel says anyone who never completed the series should simply go ahead and get it. Past 60 it is recommended with risk factors: being sexually active, travel to areas like parts of Asia and Africa, healthcare work, dialysis. Even a motor vehicle accident abroad can expose you in healthcare settings.

Answered around 26:24
Why did the 2016 switch from trivalent to bivalent oral polio vaccine fail?

Type 2 was taken out of the oral vaccine in 2016 because it caused vaccine-derived polio, and computer modeling said that would be fine. It was not: type 2 immunity fell away, OPV2 was used again, and six cases in 2016 became thousands of paralyzed children. Roland Sutter, an architect of the switch, called it an unqualified failure.

Answered around 12:42
How well did inactivated polio vaccine work in the Pakistan outbreak?

Fourteen rounds of monovalent type 2 oral vaccine and five rounds of inactivated poliovirus between September 2019 and December 2021 interrupted transmission in about two years, with not a single case diagnosed after IPV administration, nearly 100% efficacy after two or three doses. Every OPV use reseeds the environment.

Answered around 11:32
How much vaccine-derived poliovirus type 2 did the Pakistan study detect?

Of 35,724 paralytic cases and 2,804 sewage wastewater samples collected between July 2019 and March 2022, circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus type 2 turned up in 0.5% of paralytic cases, that is 181, and in 11% of sewage samples. Strains fell into 13 indigenous and two imported emergence groups.

Answered around 9:58
How many measles cases are confirmed in the United States now?

The count given is 979 total confirmed cases, while the CDC lists 982, three more that Daniel cannot account for. The Johns Hopkins measles tracker puts the year above a thousand. Hotspots include Utah, with clusters around Salt Lake City and the St. George area, plus Arizona and Florida.

Answered around 15:26
How much of the immune system does measles infection destroy?

It depends on severity: a mild case might wipe out about 30% of your immune repertoire, a more severe case ending in hospital 70 to 80%. You do not simply replace it, and holes can remain afterwards. Deliberately catching measles to kill autoreactive cells is a nuclear option Daniel will not encourage.

Answered around 38:21
Is Flublok a good flu vaccine to order for the season?

Flublok is approved from about age nine upward. Head-to-head against standard flu vaccine it looks non-inferior, with some studies suggesting slightly better, and Daniel has put it on his own order list as reasonable. Sanofi advertises it as egg-free, but the egg allergy was never really a thing.

Answered around 36:34
Key Quote

“There are lies, damn lies, and statistics.”

— Daniel Griffin, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 1:32▶ listen at 1:32
Key Quote

“I don't understand what happened to telling the truth, Daniel.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 2:30▶ listen at 2:30
Key Quote

“The switch was an unqualified failure.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 13:33▶ listen at 13:33
Key Quote

“We have thousands of paralyzed kids.”

— Daniel Griffin, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 13:51▶ listen at 13:51
Key Quote

“This is really, you know, I spent my life working on polio.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 14:09▶ listen at 14:09
Key Quote

“So across the board, getting vaccinated was safer than not getting vaccinated.”

— Daniel Griffin, Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy, at 23:57▶ listen at 23:57

Cite this

“Surgeon General Confirmation Controversy.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twiv/TWiV1300.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/surgeon-general-confirmation-controversy.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?