Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque

42:07 recording · EN · 7 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • On May 6, 2009, co-worker Catherine Frost calls police to 61-year-old Albuquerque teacher Ellen Roth's home after Ellen misses several days of work, leaving stacked newspapers, barking dogs and an overflowing food bowl behind.1:30
  • Her brother John Feeder reports her missing, notes her 2007 Dodge Caravan is gone, and names her 19-year-old adopted son Brian as his first suspect because Brian had threatened Ellen with a knife on March 25th of 2009 and stolen her debit card and jewelry in April.10:32
  • Brian is ruled out physically because he was jailed on May 1 of 2009 for a probation violation after a dirty drug test, and when Ellen's wiped-down van turns up in the International District on May 10th the case is reclassified as a homicide on May 11th.14:58
  • Four months later an informant walks into the Edgewood Police Department and names Christopher Donovan, an airman at Kirkland Air Force Base, who admits he drove Brian's wife Kathleen and her boyfriend James Johnson to Ellen's house, where James choked her to death before they buried her in a pre-dug hole in the Hemis Mountains.30:56
  • Kathleen Roth pled guilty to second-degree murder and conspiracy and received 37 and a half years, James Johnson 28 years and Christopher Donovan up to 15, while Kathleen led detectives to Ellen's body and Brian was never charged.40:32

Brief overview

Albuquerque teacher Ellen Roth was strangled in 2009 in a murder masterminded by her daughter-in-law.

  1. The obvious suspect had an airtight alibiBrian Roth had assaulted and robbed his mother, but he was in custody from May 1 on.
  2. Small details at the scene flagged foul playStacked newspapers, barricaded dogs and an overflowing food bowl suggested someone planned for days of absence.
  3. An informant, not forensics, broke the caseWith the van wiped clean and no body, the case only moved when a walk-in named Christopher Donovan.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What actually happened to Albuquerque teacher Ellen Roth?

Ellen Roth, a 61-year-old Albuquerque teacher, was killed on the morning of May 6, 2009. Her daughter-in-law Kathleen Roth and James Johnson waited in the garage, using a door opener Ellen had given Kathleen, grabbed her as she left for work, and Johnson choked her to death.

Answered around 33:52
What sentences did the three people convicted receive?

Christopher Donovan pled guilty to second-degree homicide and received up to a 15-year sentence. James Johnson took a plea for second-degree murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree murder and conspiracy to tampering with evidence, and got 28 years. Kathleen Roth pled guilty to the same counts and received 37 and a half years.

Answered around 40:08
Why would Kathleen Roth want her mother-in-law dead?

Brian's girlfriend Bella Gonzalez told investigators that when Brian was arrested, Kathleen flew into a rage and snapped, because she felt Ellen was taking Brian away from her. She had a strong sense of injustice pointed at her, wanted to avenge her husband, and pulled a lot of people in to fulfill her agenda.

Answered around 38:06
Why did detectives suspect Ellen's son Brian first?

Brian was arrested on March 25, 2009 for a domestic violence episode with Ellen, charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon after threatening her with a knife, and sentenced to a year of probation. On April 26 she reported her debit card, two diamond rings, a wedding band, a dinner ring and three necklaces missing.

Answered around 12:40
What ruled Brian out as her killer?

Brian Roth was arrested on May 1, 2009 for a probation violation. He was tested for narcotics and came back with a dirty sample, so the probation officer revoked his probation and placed him in custody. Incarcerated from May 1 on, he could have had no physical part in the killing.

Answered around 14:58
How did police finally break the case?

On September 1, four months after Ellen disappeared, an informant walked into the Edgewood Police Department. He said Christopher Donovan was responsible for the missing Albuquerque teacher going missing, that a man named James Johnson choked her until she was dead, and that James was Kathleen Roth's boyfriend.

Answered around 30:56
Where was Ellen's body found, and how?

Instead of going to trial Kathleen came clean, saying she was there and helped move the body, and agreed to lead investigators to the grave. Several detectives caravanned to a remote location in the Hemis Mountains, dug about two feet to expose a blue tarp, and contacted the Office of the Medical Investigator.

Answered around 39:29
Why were the dogs treated as a red flag?

Catherine Frost said Ellen would never have left her dogs and that this was not how she treated them; the food bowl would not be overflowing. It almost looked as though somebody had put the dogs in there knowing it would be days before they were found.

Answered around 3:35
What did Ellen's missing minivan tell investigators?

On May 10, 2009 a caller reported a probably stolen vehicle. The rear plate did not match, but the VIN came back to Ellen Roth. She lived in northeast Albuquerque and went only between school and home, so her van sitting in the International District made no sense, and it appeared freshly wiped down.

Answered around 15:46
What kind of marriage did Brian and Kathleen have?

Kathleen told detectives it was an open, polyamorous relationship: both she and Brian saw other people, and Brian was dating Bella Gonzalez. It was essentially a marriage of convenience so they could get insurance, food stamps and government subsidies, though she said they also loved each other and would always be there for each other.

Answered around 28:23
Key Quote

“Oh, yeah, like, this is, like, Twilight Zone creepy to me.”

— Kathleen Roth, Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 21:29▶ listen at 21:29
Key Quote

“I used to always tell her she was a victim of abuse, domestic violence, only by a child.”

— Catherine Frost, Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 25:12▶ listen at 25:12
Key Quote

“It's an open, polyamorous relationship.”

— Kathleen Roth, Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 28:23▶ listen at 28:23
Key Quote

“Our relationship with her wasn't a very ethical one.”

— Kathleen Roth, Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 29:06▶ listen at 29:06
Key Quote

“All they saw her as was money and a nuisance,”

— Chris Donovan, Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 34:59▶ listen at 34:59
Key Quote

“Why should they get a chance to live when Ellen doesn't get that chance?”

— Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque, at 41:05▶ listen at 41:05

Cite this

“Teacher Disappears: Mystery in Albuquerque.” https://content.production.cdn.art19.com/validation=1785738485,c22f184f-5d7b-533b-9696-e1e31f31bc02,5VBy8h0joncus5QRSm3tZEu5Ck4/episodes/583e6a6f-46ee-4015-847c-07483f2bfdc1/a58da34ec6c68bc60fa1074a089ca579cba21b073ccdec99731e02fe9e1c863a37cbee1c32b2860483216c5b26c67157a9ca475dd47a61c9f41686860b014a9c/Cathleen%20Roth%203413%20Snapped.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/teacher-disappears-mystery-in-albuquerque.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?