Debate education started early is the panel's most practical tool for reducing partisan animosity.
Kimberly Willingham says the Boston Debate League runs three programs: after-school policy debate on one resolution a year, Debate Inspired Classrooms that teach discourse, critical listening and empathy across K-12, and Resolved, created for Black and Latino young men facing barriers to policy debate.
Over 40 schools across the city of Boston, about 700 students a year, plus hundreds of teachers who then affect thousands more students. It is a $2.4 million local nonprofit, one of 22 urban debate leagues nationally, and elementary principals are now asking to join.
Jeffrey Rosen asks people to separate political from constitutional views: not whether gun control is a good or bad idea, but whether the Constitution allows or forbids it. Making that separation, like constitutional lawyers or Supreme Court justices, brings down partisan heat and makes civil dialogue possible.
All 80 clauses of the Constitution, written about by leading liberal and conservative scholars nominated by the Federalist Society and the American Constitution Society, stating what they agree on and separate statements on disagreements, such as Amy Coney Barrett and Neil Katyal on habeas corpus. 70 million hits since 2015.
Five: 18-year term limits for Supreme Court justices; making amendment a little easier; making impeachment harder in the House and conviction easier in the Senate; eliminating the natural born citizenship requirement for president; and resurrecting the legislative veto letting Congress repudiate executive actions by majority vote.
Three reasons, Rosen says: a mindful diversity of views, with real liberals and real conservatives deliberating together; privacy, since a week behind closed doors meant no one played to their base; and scholars deeply versed in constitutional text and history who could be concrete immediately.
It started with 30 kids from Title I schools, 85% minority. This past summer it ran 200 kids, from rising sixth graders through high school, three weeks for varsity and two for junior varsity and novices, who then form school teams and debate in tournaments all year.
Debaters do not know which element of the topic they will face, or whether they argue affirmative or negative, so they must put themselves inside the minds of people whose beliefs they find anathema. Every assertion needs evidence, teaching media literacy that separates misinformation from reality, done civilly.
In 2018 the legislature passed and Governor Baker signed a civic education bill: all students receive civic education between K-12, with a required project in eighth grade and another in high school. The Boston Debate League also has an earmark in the state budget.
Julia Dar suggests speaking far more often about the topics on which we have changed our mind, and asking it of campus speakers, of candidates for higher office through the media, and of students in classrooms: what have you changed your mind about, and why? A belief is not an identity.
“The central idea in all of our debates and conversations and teaching is to ask people to separate their political from their constitutional views.”
“But there's nothing equal when some people start 25 yards behind the starting blocks and others are 25 yards ahead.”
“I think if we say this is important, we have to invest in young people, and that starts in the classroom.”
“But the thing that we could all do every day every conversation is start asking people what are you changing your mind about”
“Teaching Youth about Healthy Conflict - #DisagreeBetter Colorado Roundtable.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EPq0EOjwEU. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/teaching-youth-about-healthy-conflict-disagreebetter-colorad.html.