Holmes proves the banker's son innocent: the niece and Sir George Burnwell stole the coronet's gems.
He produced a square black Morocco case holding the Beryl Coronet, one of the most precious public possessions of the Empire. It carried thirty-nine enormous beryls, the gold chasing incalculable in worth, and the lowest estimate put the coronet at double the sum he had asked.
He said it was absolutely essential that he have fifty thousand pounds at once, with a large sum due to him next Monday, when he would repay with whatever interest Holder thought right. Holder called his cashier and paid it over in fifty one-thousand-pound notes.
By evening he felt it imprudent to leave so precious a thing in the office: bankers' safes had been forced before, and why should not his be? He resolved to carry the case back and forth, drove to his house at Streatham, and locked it in his dressing-room bureau.
Peeping round his dressing-room door, he saw Arthur, dressed only in shirt and trousers, standing by the half-up gas holding the coronet and wrenching or bending it with all his strength. Arthur dropped it and turned pale; a gold corner with three beryls was missing.
Holmes revealed an understanding between Sir George Burnwell and Holder's niece Mary, who had now fled together. Burnwell, a ruined gambler and one of the most dangerous men in England, made her his tool; she carried the coronet downstairs and handed it out through the hall window.
Having watched Mary pass it out, he rushed down barefoot, sprang through the window into the snow, and chased the dark figure down the lane. He caught Sir George, struck him over the eye in the struggle, the coronet snapped, and he carried it back to straighten it.
He could not explain without betraying Mary, the cousin he loved and had repeatedly asked to marry. He took the chivalrous view and preserved her secret through insults, arrest and a night in a cell. His plea for five minutes outside was to hunt the missing fragment.
In the stable lane he found a double line of a booted man's tracks and a second double line made by naked feet. The bare feet had run, and their tread lay over the boot marks, so they passed later. Cut-up snow and blood marked the struggle.
Dressed as a common loafer, he went to Sir George's house, picked up an acquaintance with the valet, and learned that his master had cut his head the night before. For six shillings he bought a pair of cast-off shoes, and at Streatham they exactly fitted the tracks.
Holmes priced the stones at one thousand pounds apiece; Holder said he would pay ten thousand. Holmes answered that three thousand would cover the matter, with a little reward besides, and told him to make the cheque out for four thousand pounds. Burnwell had sold them for six hundred.
“You villain! you thief! How dare you touch that coronet!”
“Keep your forgiveness for those who ask for it,”
“My God, what shall I do? I have lost my honour, my gems, and my son, in one night.”
“I feel it give a little, but, though I am exceptionally strong in the fingers, it would take me all my time to break it.”
“You owe a very humble apology to that noble lad, your son,”
“there has been an understanding between sir george burnwell and eunice mary they have now fled together.”
“The Berrell Coronet Mystery.” https://www.archive.org/download/adventures_holmes/adventureholmes_11_doyle_64kb.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/the-berrell-coronet-mystery.html.
Showing the first 40 of 518 lines.