Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

The Crash: Family's Defense

44:28 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • On July 31st, 2022, 17-year-old Mackenzie crashed a car at nearly 100 miles per hour into a brick building, killing her boyfriend Dom and their friend Davion; she survived, chose a bench trial, never testified, and was convicted of murder.1:08
  • Her father Steve has given several post-Netflix interviews, telling Chris Cuomo there was no evidence, that speeding is recklessness rather than murder, that it should have been vehicular homicide in juvenile court, and that if the black box convicted her then they should put the car in jail.2:56
  • When Cuomo called Mackenzie and Dom's relationship volatile, Steve laughed and called it a lie, insisting they were talking about marriage and buying furniture, while the host's FOIA reading shows constant fights, Mackenzie threatening to break open Dom's front door, and Dom accusing her of sex work.11:31
  • Police reports and body cam audio show Natalie's first concern at the hospital was what people were posting on the Strongsville Facebook page, that she reported two girls for mean messages but never emailed the promised screenshots, and that Mackenzie was messaging a friend about Skims 20 days after the crash.20:25
  • Steve explains the 'boom' graphic tee he wore on Netflix as a thank-you to YouTuber Crime Circus, a defender of his daughter, then jokes about his orange polo, and Natalie tells the Daily Mail she is not a villain and neither is her daughter.37:29

Brief overview

Mackenzie's parents keep defending her in public interviews, and every appearance only makes their family look worse.

  1. Silence would have served this family betterThe host opens on why defense attorneys keep clients off the stand, then spends the episode showing the Shirillas doing the opposite.
  2. Steve's arguments collapse under his own hypotheticalsCuomo answers each 'what if' — POTS, the boys, the car — by pointing out that every one of them would simply make it an accident.
  3. The record contradicts the parents' versionFOIA material, school reports, body cam audio and Snapchat extracts describe fights, a fake ID search and post-crash shopping chat the interviews never mention.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What happened in the crash that led to Mackenzie Shirilla's murder conviction?

On July 31st, 2022, 17-year-old Mackenzie crashed a car going nearly 100 miles per hour straight into a brick building. Her boyfriend Dom, in the front passenger seat, and their friend Davion, in the back seat, were both killed. Mackenzie was the only survivor and is now a convicted murderer.

Answered around 1:08
How does Steve Shirilla argue the crash was not intentional?

He says the black box data only describes the car: he cannot explain the acceleration or why the pedal was down. A slipper stuck on the pedal, which was refuted, or a car fault is just as likely as intent. Speeding is recklessness, not murder, so it should have been vehicular homicide in juvenile court.

Answered around 5:49
How did Steve react when Chris Cuomo called Dom and Mackenzie's relationship volatile?

Steve laughed and called it a lie. He said the kids fought, broke up and got back together, but were talking about getting married and buying furniture for a house. He claimed the prosecution needed that narrative to put his daughter in a bad light and suggest she had something against Dom.

Answered around 12:06
What do the FOIA records show about Mackenzie and Dom's relationship?

The hosts say the FOIA documents contain never-ending fights between Mackenzie and Dom, including Mackenzie threatening to break open the front door to be let into his house, refusing to leave him alone, and a recurring fight in which Dom accused her of engaging in sex work.

Answered around 12:51
Why did Steve Shirilla lose his job after the Netflix documentary?

Steve Shirilla, an art teacher at a Catholic school, was placed on leave because of comments he made in the viral Netflix documentary The Crash. Reactions to the family's appearance ranged from people hating the dad and mocking his shirt to rumors of an inappropriate relationship between Mackenzie and her father.

Answered around 2:09
Why did Steve wear the shirt that says boom in the Netflix documentary?

He said the boom shirt came from Drip Drop, merch from Crime Circus, a YouTuber who had defended Mackenzie and posted evidence claiming she is innocent. Steve said he wore it to thank him, calling him a good champion against injustice, and denied being insensitive to the two boys who died.

Answered around 39:30
What was Natalie Shirilla's first concern after the crash, according to Dom's mom and police?

Dom's mom told the judge that when she called Natalie, the first thing Natalie said was not to listen to what everyone was saying on Facebook. Officers agreed, saying her biggest concern at the hospital was posts on the Strongsville Facebook page and whether police could intervene.

Answered around 20:00
Why do defense attorneys often advise clients not to testify at their own trial?

Many defense attorneys believe how a person comes across to the jury matters more than what they actually say. Once someone involved starts talking, jurors focus less on facts and more on whether they like and trust the person, so in most cases testifying is not worth it.

Answered around 0:31
What did Mackenzie's Snapchat files reveal about the passport-style photos?

The Snapchat data contained many photos of Mackenzie against a white wall in different poses. Based on context clues, the hosts concluded she was sending them to fake ID websites to buy a fake ID online, since she also had screenshots of herself applying for fake IDs on those sites.

Answered around 31:32
What did Mackenzie say about the modeling school her family paid for?

In a Snapchat audio note she called it the worst class of her life and said it felt like a scam. Her family paid $4,000, she expected to be placed immediately, but it was slow and repetitive like cosmetology school, and she insulted classmates, saying only five girls were hot.

Answered around 33:56
Key Quote

“Sometimes shutting up is the best answer.”

— The Crash: Family's Defense, at 0:00▶ listen at 0:00
Key Quote

“And she is now a convicted murderer.”

— The Crash: Family's Defense, at 1:23▶ listen at 1:23
Key Quote

“The whole interview is a dumpster fire.”

— The Crash: Family's Defense, at 10:02▶ listen at 10:02
Key Quote

“Maybe don't wear the boom shirt.”

— The Crash: Family's Defense, at 38:01▶ listen at 38:01

Cite this

“The Crash: Family's Defense.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/ca05dec2-017c-4888-bda3-ab746f266395/episodes/30eb37fc-baaa-4554-a274-e861dc1eac0e/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_75b3ede08d2772a0e6a295da887b5afb_42694414.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/the-crash-family-s-defense.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?