Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

The Odyssey Movie Review

54:30 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The Critical Drinker says Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey turned contentious mainly over casting, after Lupita Nyong'o was announced as Helen of Troy and Elliot Page joined, though both are onscreen for about five minutes.3:36
  • He stands by his review's verdict that the film is "meh" — slow, emotionally sterile and loose with Odysseus, turned from a hero longing for home into a Vietnam vet with PTSD.8:06
  • As counter-evidence that cinema still works, he points to Obsession, made for $750,000 and now sitting at around $450 million, on track to be the most profitable film ever relative to budget.16:31
  • He argues Hollywood, Marvel included, only pivoted away from identity-politics pandering after tens of billions of dollars in lost revenue over roughly a decade, with Star Trek, Star Wars and Indiana Jones left as casualties.20:20
  • The loss of DVD income, he says, removed the second lease of life that made risky films profitable, leaving studios dependent on proven IPs and endless franchise sequels.31:22

Brief overview

The Odyssey is merely fine, and the hype around it shows how rare good films became.

  1. Hype now outruns the actual qualityA film that would have been called okay 20 years ago is hailed as one of the greatest ever made.
  2. A good hook beats a huge budgetObsession cost $750,000, took roughly $450 million, and made a star of an unknown lead.
  3. Safe, coddled artists make duller workToday's manufactured actors lack the tough backgrounds that shaped Steve McQueen, Kirk Douglas and Charles Bronson.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why did The Odyssey attract so much online backlash before release?

The pushback came from the casting revealed with the first trailer: Lupita Nyong'o as Helen of Troy, and Elliot Page, first assumed to be playing Achilles. Early enthusiasm for a Christopher Nolan take on the Odyssey turned into vitriol not seen since Rachel Zegler's Snow White.

Answered around 3:36
What is the Critical Drinker's actual verdict on Nolan's Odyssey?

He stands by his review: it's meh. He didn't hate it and didn't love it, it sits in the middle. He found it a slog, very slow paced, lacking emotional resonance and urgency, and taking a lot of liberties with the characters, while praising some technical aspects.

Answered around 8:01
How does the film change Odysseus from the original poem?

Nolan takes quite a few liberties with the characterisation. Instead of a brave adventurer with a burning desire to get home to his family, Odysseus becomes basically a Vietnam vet with PTSD and survivor's guilt. Changing his motivation changes the meaning of the whole story.

Answered around 6:09
How much screen time do Lupita Nyong'o and Elliot Page actually get?

The two of them are in the movie for a grand total of about five minutes, in a Christopher Nolan film that runs something like seven hours. They are ancillary to the main story, the focus is on other characters, and the casting didn't affect his perception of the film.

Answered around 5:22
Why do so many performances in The Odyssey feel flat?

Because Nolan has no reputation as an actor's director. From what the Drinker is told, he hands over the script and tells actors to figure the performance out themselves. So Jon Bernthal plays Menelaus as every tough guy he's played, Tom Holland gives nothing. Nolan directs ideas, not people.

Answered around 14:14
What do Obsession's numbers prove about budgets in horror?

It cost $750,000 to make and is sitting at around $450 million, on track to be the most profitable film of all time relative to budget. With horror all you need is a good idea and hook, a decent script and some good actors, not a huge budget or big special effects.

Answered around 16:31
Is Hollywood moving away from identity politics in its franchises?

Yes. The pivots are visible in the bigger franchises, with Marvel a good example, away from political identity-politics pandering. It took tens of billions of dollars in lost revenue over roughly a decade to realise it, and Star Trek, Star Wars and Indiana Jones were casualties in the process.

Answered around 19:48
How did the death of DVD change which movies get made?

DVD was factored into the financial model: a film that didn't quite turn a profit at the box office would make about 50% more in rentals and sales later. That let studios take chances on unproven concepts. In the post-physical media world everything leans on proven IP and endless franchise sequels.

Answered around 31:22
Why is Project Hail Mary working so well with audiences?

It is entirely about adventure, science and friendship, universal themes anyone can watch, with no politics or pandering, and you don't need to be a hardcore science fiction nut. It makes the material accessible, and it gives Rocky more likability and humanity than all the CGI Star Wars characters combined.

Answered around 22:51
Was Zendaya miscast as Athena, and why does it matter?

He calls her horribly miscast, frowning a lot as her role. Athena should be majestic and imposing, a mixture of warrior and intellectual, but she comes across as Odysseus's conscience rather than a goddess with agency, agendas and flaws, which is not how the Greeks saw their gods.

Answered around 52:06
Key Quote

“It's like, how many movies have you watched?”

— Critical Drinker, The Odyssey Movie Review, at 1:11▶ listen at 1:11
Key Quote

“Christopher Nolan doesn't direct people he directs ideas”

— Critical Drinker, The Odyssey Movie Review, at 14:51▶ listen at 14:51
Key Quote

“It's not that hard, but they made it hard.”

— Critical Drinker, The Odyssey Movie Review, at 18:21▶ listen at 18:21
Key Quote

“And he went, dude, everyone's terrified.”

— Trigonometry host, The Odyssey Movie Review, at 40:36▶ listen at 40:36

Cite this

“The Odyssey Movie Review.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/AALT8613751885.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/the-odyssey-movie-review.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?