Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why)

13:01 recording · AUTO · 1 speaker

Watch the original

Executive Summary AI
  • Alex tells the Copy Posse she is breaking down five ads and the psychological principles behind them, and floats a three-part series adding landing pages and emails.
  • Volkswagen's Think Small, launched in 1959, made the Beetle the number one best-selling imported car in the USA by the mid-1960s by naming its own flaw, which Robert Cialdini's Persuasion describes as a way to build trust.
  • Apple's Get a Mac ads with Justin Long and John Hodgman, and The Economist's one-line print ads such as "I never read The Economist. Management trainee aged 42", both sell identity, status and ego rather than features.
  • Huel's Facebook ad uses visual comparison against an unnamed status quo instant noodle: both take five minutes to prepare, but Huel's have more protein, vitamins and minerals and are vegan.
  • Her own personal brand bootcamp ads used the challenge common belief hook, with the static banner taking nearly 40% of total ad sales and a native Instagram ad converting at nearly 9% against a 1-2% average.

Brief overview

Five ads work because they admit flaws, sell identity and status, compare visually, and challenge beliefs.

  1. Admit a flaw to buy believabilityVolkswagen owned the Beetle's size instead of claiming to be the fastest or sexiest car.
  2. Sell the identity, then show the proofGet a Mac and The Economist let viewers picture the person they want to be perceived as.
  3. Compare visually without naming the competitorHuel set its noodles beside the generic instant noodle: same five minutes, more protein and vegan.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Which five psychological principles does she say to copy in your own ads?

Admitting a flaw, identity marketing, playing to the reader's sense of status and ego, comparison, and challenging common beliefs. Alex presents them as the five principles you should absolutely replicate in your own advertising, drawn from the Volkswagen, Apple, Economist, Huel and Copy Posse ads she breaks down.

Why does Volkswagen's Think Small ad work so well?

Because it directly calls out a flaw, something that could easily be perceived as negative by the customer, and turns it into a key selling point. It hooks attention by naming a common objection immediately, rather than claiming to be the sexiest, fastest or best car, then addresses those objections in the copy itself.

What does Robert Cialdini say about admitting a flaw?

In his book Persuasion, Cialdini describes admitting a flaw, or something that isn't perfect about you or your products, as a great way to increase trust and believability. Volkswagen did exactly that, over and over. Believability and trust are always more persuasive than bold claims, fancy branding and flashy messaging.

Why is Apple's Get a Mac campaign so persuasive?

It is show-don't-tell marketing. The ads never have to say that Mac is simpler, cooler or more user-friendly, because the point is instantly understandable. They use humour to poke fun at the PC's flaws and play on status and ego: nobody wants to be seen as the PC guy with the virus.

What does The Economist print ad actually say?

It reads simply, "I never read The Economist. Management trainee, aged 42." Sister lines include "lose the ability to slip out of meetings unnoticed," "some people just get it," and "essential guide for those going places." All imply that reading it makes you a little wiser and smarter.

How does Huel's instant noodle ad use comparison?

Huel uses the psychological principle of comparison, shown visually: a side-by-side of its instant noodles against the status quo noodle everyone knows, without naming the competitor brand. Both take only five minutes to prepare, but the Huel noodles have far more protein, vitamins and minerals, and they are vegan.

What is the challenge common belief hook?

A hook that challenges a belief the reader holds, then introduces a new idea that grabs attention. The bootcamp headline read: "Why you need a personal brand in 2025. The most booked freelancers won't just be the most skilled, they'll be the most trusted," challenging the belief that skills are all that matter.

What is a native ad and why does it work?

Native ads are designed to match the look, feel and context of the surrounding content or platform, blending in seamlessly with organic content so they feel less disruptive and more engaging. Most of us have become banner blind and subconsciously scroll straight past anything that obviously looks like an ad.

How well did the Instagram native ad convert?

It had a nearly 9% conversion rate on Instagram, against an average of only 1 to 2%. It began as a simple organic Instagram post that performed so well the team later turned it into an ad for the personal brand bootcamp, with the challenge common beliefs hook written into the caption.

What results did the Think Small campaign produce for Volkswagen?

The campaign first launched in 1959, and by the mid-1960s the Volkswagen Beetle had become the number one best-selling imported car in the USA. It helped Volkswagen break into the US market and ushered in a form of advertising built on honesty and simplicity over flashy graphics and exaggerated claims.

Key Quote

“Ever read an ad and think, oh my god, I have to buy this? Yes, that is not an accident.”

— Alex, These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why), at 0:00▶ watch at 0:00
Key Quote

“Everyone wants people to think that they're more like the Mac guy.”

— Alex, These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why), at 4:52▶ watch at 4:52
Key Quote

“I love it when marketing really makes you pause and think, right?”

— Alex, These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why), at 5:29▶ watch at 5:29
Key Quote

“We're saying what you've been thinking about personal branding is all wrong.”

— Alex, These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why), at 10:34▶ watch at 10:34
Key Quote

“Not only is social media the new search engine, it is also the new resume.”

— Alex, These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why), at 12:01▶ watch at 12:01

Cite this

“These 5 Ads Crushed It (Here's Why).” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEsLSUOpgKw. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/these-5-ads-crushed-it-here-s-why.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?