Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Trainers and the Rise of Nike

1:11:15 recording · EN · 5 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In the late 1970s Phil Knight opened the morning mail to find a US Customs invoice for past due duties of $25 million, the exact same number as Nike's total sales for the year.2:03
  • The bill came from an arcane 1920s-30s rule called American selling price, which set duties not on what an imported shoe cost but on what a similar American-made shoe would sell for, doubling the charge in Ed Conway's worked example from $1 to $2.19:26
  • Nike's counter-move was the One Line, an unbranded 1980 knock-off of its own Oceana made cheaply in America and sold at almost no profit to lower the reference price; it cut the duty increase by two-thirds, Nike settled for $9 million rather than $25 million, and ASP was eliminated from the entire US customs code.24:24
  • Winning that battle in 1980 opened Pandora's box: Adidas, Converse, New Balance, Puma and Reebok all followed Nike's design-here, make-it-in-Asia model, and production chased cheaper labour from Japan to Korea and Taiwan, then China, then Vietnam after trade relations resumed in 1995.31:41
  • Patrick McGee argues Apple put the same model on steroids and was captured by China, while China, reading the smile curve as inverted at the national level, took the supposedly low-value middle and built capabilities in smartphones, solar panels and batteries on top of it.54:34

Brief overview

Nike's fight over a $25 million customs bill launched the outsourcing model that reshaped global manufacturing.

  1. A shoe designed as a legal weaponThe One Line carried no swoosh because its whole job was to lower the American selling price Nike's imports were measured against.
  2. Nike sold the smile curve, not shoesGary Jareffi's curve puts value in design and marketing at the ends; Nike kept those and left the making of the trainers to contract factories in Asia.
  3. Asia captured skills, not just cheap ordersTaiwan went from making trainers to making the world's most advanced silicon chips, and Chinese brands like Anta and Li Ning now sign athletes such as Steph Curry.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How big was the US Customs bill that nearly killed Nike?

Phil Knight opened the morning mail to find a letterhead reading United States Customs, with an invoice attached for past due customs duties of $25 million — the exact same number as Nike's total sales for the year. He said he had no idea what they were talking about.

Answered around 2:03
What was the American Selling Price rule?

An arcane American law dating back to the 1920s and 1930s, when cheap imports of chemicals, clams and shoes came from Europe. Duty was calculated not on the manufacturer's cost but on what a similar American-made product cost: a $5 Japanese trainer taxed as if it cost $10, doubling the charge from $1 to $2.

Answered around 19:26
Why did Nike make an unbranded trainer called the One Line?

It was designed to hack the American selling price rules. Nike knocked off one of its own shoes, the Oceana, removed all the branding, produced a limited line in America and sold it to discounters at almost no profit, then submitted it to US customs so the American comparison price fell.

Answered around 22:50
Did the One Line work, and what did Nike finally pay?

Over a couple of years it sold a couple thousand pairs and reduced the increase in duties by two-thirds. By 1980 Nike could afford the bill, settling with the government for $9 million rather than $25 million, and ASP was eliminated from the entire US customs code.

Answered around 23:33
Why did Blue Ribbon become Nike with its own brand and swoosh?

Onitsuka's new leadership attempted a hostile takeover: its CEO offered to buy 51% of the company at book value, or else set up other distributors. Knight refused, and after a long, painful legal battle he and his team were forced, more by circumstance than anything else, to create the Nike brand.

Answered around 11:40
Why did Phil Knight look to Japan to make running shoes?

For his Stanford business school project he asked whether, if you were starting a shoe factory, you would start it in Germany. The answer was that it is such a labour-intensive business it makes more sense in Japan, the country that had taken the camera market from German makers.

Answered around 8:25
What is the smile curve and where did Nike sit on it?

Production sits in the middle of the curve, pre-production activities like R&D and design on the left, post-production marketing on the right. Nike's focus was pre and post-production, the two high ends, and that is where they made their big money, leaving the actual making of trainers to others.

Answered around 17:18
Which companies actually manufacture the world's trainers today?

Taiwanese and Korean-owned contract manufacturers are still the largest players in the entire industry: Pao Chen and the Wali Group out of Taiwan, and Taekwong for Korea. Some have revenue that dwarfs the brands. A pair of Nikes and a pair of Adidas may come from the same factory.

Answered around 39:02
Did Nike and Adidas ever try bringing production back home?

In 2015 both tried, building highly automated speed factories close to consumers to cut the gap between a trend and the store from 18 months to about six. Adidas found no German shoemaker and used a car company for plastic extrusion, shrinking a 65-part shoe to 15-18 parts. In 2019 they called it a failure.

Answered around 1:03:01
How much more would trainers cost if made in America or Europe?

Tony Le says consumers do not want to pay $400 or $500 for a pair of shoes, they want to pay $150. Made in the US or Europe, even applying minimum wage rather than a living wage, you would see the product sold for twice or three times its current price.

Answered around 1:05:31
Key Quote

“I had no idea what they were talking about.”

— Phil Knight, Trainers and the Rise of Nike, at 2:09▶ listen at 2:09
Key Quote

“Supply chains are the nervous system of globalization.”

— Patrick McGee, Trainers and the Rise of Nike, at 46:25▶ listen at 46:25
Key Quote

“So I call them captured by China.”

— Patrick McGee, Trainers and the Rise of Nike, at 56:28▶ listen at 56:28
Key Quote

“Consumers don't want to pay $400 or $500 for a pair of shoes.”

— Tony Le, Trainers and the Rise of Nike, at 1:05:20▶ listen at 1:05:20

Cite this

“Trainers and the Rise of Nike.” https://dax.captivate.fm/3e84e7f0-bdae-40f2-bd9a-a9db168d6ed6/Stuff-Matters-Trainers-MAIN-FINAL-FINAL-encoded.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/trainers-and-the-rise-of-nike.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?