Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Twins DNA Mystery

36:17 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode

Brief overview

Non-DNA evidence, not the identical twins' DNA, convicts 13-year-old Levi Cart of murdering neighbor Denise Tenpenny.

  1. Identical twin DNA forces non-DNA evidenceWith both boys matching the DNA, the case turned on the watch under the body, the glove fragment, the boots and the phones.
  2. Levi's phone built the case against himTikTok messages about low empathy, serial killer MO screenshots, strangulation research and post-murder Fairfax searches all sat on Levi's device, not Hunter's.
  3. Hunter refused to believe it until the photoHe argued coincidence, planted evidence and his brother's empathy, then hyperventilated and put his head on the table when shown the watch.
Executive Summary AI
  • Part two picks up the Cart twins case: 64-year-old Denise Tenpenny was essayed and murdered in her own bed, and DNA led investigators 50 feet across the street to 13-year-old identical twin brothers whose DNA is the same.0:12
  • Because DNA cannot separate identical twins, investigators lean on other evidence and tell the twins' mother Becca that one twin's watch was found under Denise's body, along with a piece of a green nitrile glove at the scene, a box of the same gloves in his closet, and bloody L.L. Bean boots in his room.2:20
  • Levi's devices carry TikTok messages about having very low empathy and killing cats, dogs and squirrels, screenshots of serial killers' MOs and how strangulation works, and post-murder searches for Fairfax, Ohio Police Department, Ted Bundy's kill kit and ways cops mess with you in the interview room, while Hunter's phone was off during the crime and shows only normal local news reading.7:12
  • Hunter spends his interview defending Levi, saying there is no way his brother could rape and kill someone, offering a planted-watch theory and a blood-transfusion-style explanation, before breaking down when shown the crime scene photo of the watch.11:59
  • No confession comes out of either interview, but on November 10th of 2025 Levi Cart pleads guilty to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary and strangulation, receives the maximum juvenile sentence, stays in juvenile detention until he turns 21, and is expected to be released in 2033.34:12
Key Quote
“I don't think that murder is stupid though”
— Levi5:35
Key Quote
“i have very low empathy which has been confirmed also my plan i'm on track found my mo”
— Levi7:17
Key Quote
“I've killed animals before on my own with a knife.”
— Levi8:10