Non-DNA evidence, not the identical twins' DNA, convicts 13-year-old Levi Cart of murdering neighbor Denise Tenpenny.
Denise Tenpenny, 64, was assaulted and murdered in her own home, in her own bed. The only thing left behind was DNA evidence, and that evidence led investigators right across the street, about 50 feet away from Denise's home, to two people living opposite her.
Answered around 0:12The DNA led to 13-year-old identical twin brothers, so technically their DNA is identical. Police decided they thought only one of the twins was involved, and brought both twins in with their mother to be interrogated separately. When identical twin DNA is involved, investigators look for evidence that is not DNA related.
Answered around 0:39On November 10th of 2025, Levi Cart pleaded guilty to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary and strangulation. He received the maximum sentence allowed under juvenile law: he will remain in the juvenile detention facility until he turns 21, and he is expected to be released in 2033.
Answered around 34:12His watch was found under Denise's body. Investigators also recovered a piece of a green nitrile glove at the scene and a box of the same green nitrile gloves in his closet, plus a pair of bloody L.L. Bean boots with visible staining in his room.
Answered around 3:52In the drawer of the left nightstand they found the book Confessions of a Serial Killer and a brown leather journal. Its first page had Levi's name, the second page read "I will kill you, k k k killer" in big chunky blocky letters, and the last page held handwritten instructions on balancing on one leg.
Answered around 6:25He messaged that he had very low empathy, that his plan was on track and that he had found his MO, and that he liked hurting animals in his childhood. He said he had killed animals with a knife, naming cats, dogs and some squirrels, and asked whether the person was sadistic.
Answered around 7:17Fairfax, Ohio Police Department and its photos, Fairfax Ohio photos, whether Ohio has restrictions on familial DNA searches, Ted Bundy's diagnosis and kill kit, and Fairfax Ohio woman found dead. Later came saliva drug tests, saliva swabs, juvenile detention center Cincinnati, Hamilton County youth center and ways cops mess with you in the interview room.
Answered around 9:26At 12:53 a.m. Hunter plugged his phone into the charger and locked the screen. Levi locked his phone at 2:12 a.m. and Hunter at 2:19 a.m. From 2:30 to 2:52 a.m., roughly 20 minutes, Levi was using his camera, and at 5:21 a.m. he unlocked his phone again.
Answered around 8:42Executing the search warrant, officers found Marshmallow calm and approachable, flopping over so they could pet his tummy despite the house being turned over. That is when they noticed his claws were specifically too small to make the injuries on the face, including the scratch on the nose that took five stitches.
Answered around 6:10His reaction to everything didn't strike them as someone involved, and aside from the DNA match, which is identical to Levi's, there was really zero evidence tying him to it: nothing in his phone, his journals or his room, and no scratches on his face or body.
Answered around 11:39“I don't think that murder is stupid though”
“i have very low empathy which has been confirmed also my plan i'm on track found my mo”
“I've killed animals before on my own with a knife.”
“And I just want you guys to know that I have no faith that my brother would be able to do something like that”
“i'm just going to tell you right now i don't believe that it's not possible it's just not possible”
“i just think that there's a lot of different types of people in the world there's not monsters and people who commit mistakes”
“Twins DNA Mystery.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/ca05dec2-017c-4888-bda3-ab746f266395/episodes/d93cb3cf-e7f9-431b-8b2f-e06ef66a88a9/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_34608b8bc0cb00b76cbf9027438344b2_35043119.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/twins-dna-mystery.html.