Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Vaccine Safety Poll Critique

46:59 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • TWIV episode 1314, recorded April 16th, 2026, has Vincent Racaniello hosting Daniel Griffin in person at the Incubator in New York for the weekly clinical update.0:10
  • They tear apart a widely shared poll claiming more Americans doubt vaccine safety than trust it, arguing its questions are biased and noting that over 90% of parents in this country approve of vaccines for their children.3:02
  • A New York Times article by Apoorva Mandavilli reports that the acting CDC head delayed an MMWR study showing COVID vaccination cut COVID emergency visits by 50% and hospitalizations by 55%, which Vincent calls a lie and politically driven, since Bhattacharya is a health economist who would not know how to interpret the statistics.5:33
  • A JAMA Oncology cohort of 615,155 vaccinated and 2,290,623 unvaccinated males aged 9 to 26, matched to 510,260 per group, found a hazard ratio of 0.54 for HPV-related cancers, about a 50% reduction, with the curves separating most by nine years.15:53
  • A Danish Eurosurveillance study of 202,785 first-ever admissions for myocardial infarction or stroke, 4,916 of them in PCR-confirmed influenza cases, found stroke risk almost threefold and heart attack fivefold in the first week after a positive flu test, roughly halved in those vaccinated that season.23:54

Brief overview

Daniel Griffin and Vincent Racaniello review new evidence that vaccines prevent cancer, heart attacks and deaths.

  1. Badly written poll questions manufacture vaccine doubtAsking whether the facts on vaccines are still up for debate tests opinion, not knowledge, while over 90% of parents approve vaccines for their children.
  2. Good vaccine data was held back for politicsThe delayed MMWR report showed COVID vaccination cut emergency visits 50% and hospitalizations 55% — the reason given for review, that it is routine, is not how MMWR works.
  3. Vaccines prevent cancer and cardiac eventsNine-valent HPV vaccination halved HPV-related cancers in males (hazard ratio 0.54), and flu vaccination halved the post-influenza spike in heart attack and stroke.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Does the 9-valent HPV vaccine reduce HPV-related cancers in males?

Yes. A JAMA Oncology retrospective cohort matched about 510,260 vaccinated and unvaccinated males aged 9 to 26. Vaccinated males had a hazard ratio of 0.54 for head and neck, esophageal, anal and penile cancers, roughly a 50% reduction, with the curves separating further by nine years of follow-up.

Answered around 17:12
Does flu vaccination lower the risk of heart attack and stroke after influenza?

A Danish study in Eurosurveillance of adults 40 or older found admissions for stroke nearly threefold and heart attack fivefold higher in the first week after a positive flu test. That increased risk was about half as high in people who had received that season's flu vaccine.

Answered around 24:42
What did the delayed CDC report find about COVID vaccine effectiveness last winter?

The report, held back by acting CDC head Bhattacharya, found COVID vaccination cut emergency visits for COVID by 50% and hospitalizations by 55%. The hosts say CDC heads do not normally review MMWR papers and that the delay was politically driven because the results favored the vaccines.

Answered around 7:03
How many measles cases has the US had so far in 2026?

The Johns Hopkins tracker counts 1,802 cases and the CDC 1,714 confirmed, nearing 2,000 by mid-April. South Carolina's outbreak may be coming under control, but Utah already has 405 cases. Last year's total was 2,242, which will likely be exceeded by summer.

Answered around 21:33
How many children have died of flu this season, and were they vaccinated?

There have been 139 pediatric flu deaths this season. About 90% of the children were unvaccinated and most had no pre-existing illnesses. A few years ago most US children got flu shots; now only a minority do, so children are not being protected.

Answered around 23:13
What symptoms do children with long COVID have, and how are they managed?

In 214 patients at Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital in Ohio, common conditions were fatigue 85%, headache 75%, dizziness 64.5%, anxiety 62% and nausea 60%. Interventions included dietary changes 82%, pacing 66%, sleep hygiene 61% and other self-care 47%. Scores were worse than national norms.

Answered around 36:52
How did COVID affect unclaimed burials on New York's Hart Island?

Hart Island deaths began deviating in early March 2020 and peaked five weeks later at 22 times the same week of 2019. Excess death rates were more than twice as high in the Bronx, and about 10% of COVID-related excess deaths during the initial outbreak were unclaimed.

Answered around 32:14
Could vampire bats spread chronic wasting disease to livestock and humans?

A Journal of Mammalogy article suggests common vampire bats feeding on prion-positive deer could accumulate prion exposure and spread it through feeding and guano, as chronic wasting disease moves south and the bats move north. The hosts call it speculation but support surveillance, such as testing guano for prions.

Answered around 12:56
Should someone over 65 get a COVID vaccine every six months?

Yes. A 74-year-old listener's chart said she was due six months after her last dose while her doctor said wait a year. Daniel Griffin says the science-based recommendation for people over 65 is a shot every six months, so she should follow the MyChart reminder.

Answered around 40:55
Is it okay to use Paxlovid that expired in April 2023?

Daniel Griffin jokes to put a sticky note reading EXP 2027 on the box. Expiration dates are required by law, but over time there has not been significant degradation of these products, so he would not see using the unopened, expired Paxlovid as a problem.

Answered around 39:59
Key Quote

“No, because the questions they ask them suck.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 3:29▶ listen at 3:29
Key Quote

“So this guy, Andrew Nixon, just is so smarmy.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 7:26▶ listen at 7:26
Key Quote

“The head of CDC does not review articles for MMWR.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 7:37▶ listen at 7:37
Key Quote

“These were happy, healthy kids until they got the flu and died.”

— Daniel Griffin, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 23:26▶ listen at 23:26
Key Quote

“So, yeah, if you vaccinate against flu, you're going to prevent heart disease.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 27:47▶ listen at 27:47
Key Quote

“When Bhattacharya said, let it rip, that was a bad idea.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Vaccine Safety Poll Critique, at 38:22▶ listen at 38:22

Cite this

“Vaccine Safety Poll Critique.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twiv/TWiV1314.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/vaccine-safety-poll-critique.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?