Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Warm Milk Controversy

1:05:40 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The hosts open the second half of part three by walking through the police FOIA file, a lengthy Cellebrite extract of text messages between Mackenzie Shirilla and her father Steve.0:40
  • They address the viral "warm milk" messages sent at 2:43 a.m. and 3 a.m. between January and May 2020, and the TikTok theories behind them, including a comment reading "warm milk is not warm milk" with almost 30,000 likes and another with over 40,000 likes claiming warm milk helps you come down from drugs.2:32
  • The texts show Steve allegedly supplying alcohol and power washing the deck for a party at their house, Mackenzie asking about weed seeds in February 2020, and Steve saying in an interview that he picked his battles and let her smoke weed.8:33
  • A Starbucks order escalates into abuse and threats, and a fight over a bumper sticker and gas ends with Steve billing her $74 for the service and $25 for his hour, yet the next day he is texting her to have fun.16:58
  • Prosecutors' brief and the Instagram data, about 2,000 pages, include a section on possible prostitution and DMs offering money, including a $600 weekly "sugar baby" allowance, though the hosts stress there is no solid evidence anything came of it.54:54

Brief overview

Mackenzie Shirilla's seized texts show parents who served her rather than parented her.

  1. The parent-child dynamic is invertedMackenzie orders her father around for milk, Starbucks and photo edits, and he complies.
  2. Discipline never carries a consequenceSteve does snap back about respect, but the next day it is "have fun, text me if you need me."
  3. Online theories outrun the actual evidenceThe warm milk and sex work rabbit holes both end without proof in the FOIA file.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What are the "warm milk" texts between Mackenzie and her dad?

In the FOIA Cellebrite extract Mackenzie repeatedly texts Steve for warm milk at odd hours: 2:43 a.m. on 4 January 2020, 11:31 p.m. two days later, 11:12 p.m. on 2 April, midnight on 5 May and 3 a.m. on 8 May 2020. He often replies hours later.

Answered around 0:56
What do people online think "warm milk" actually means?

A TikTok comment reading "warm milk is not warm milk" has almost 30,000 likes. Commenters argue it helps someone come down from drugs; another with over 40,000 likes says a child of addicts was told that. Others call it sexual, or cite Urban Dictionary definitions.

Answered around 2:32
What else did Mackenzie ask her father to do for her?

She used him almost as a butler: hot cocoa, tanning oil, spray paint, cardboard stencils, pants, and photo editing — "did you fix the pic? I need you to fix it ASAP. I'm trying to post." She also demanded he book her a massage earlier than 7.

Answered around 4:29
Did her parents help her get alcohol and weed?

Texting Dom about alcohol, Mackenzie said her dad told her to make it with vodka, then confirmed he got the orange liquor, and said he was power washing the deck for their party. She also texted that her dad asked if she knew anyone with female weed seeds.

Answered around 8:33
What did Steve say about letting his daughter smoke weed?

Steve said in an interview that he picked his battles and let Mackenzie smoke weed: "I'm sorry if I find marijuana not that dangerous as I find alcohol or cocaine or whatever... she seemed mature enough to handle it. I didn't see it as an issue."

Answered around 11:02
How did Mackenzie speak to her father in the car fights?

Over a bumper sticker she texted, "never fucking put that on my car again... I will seriously flip the fuck out." Steve replied "lol" and later "thanks for the laugh." In another fight he billed her $74 for servicing and $25 for his wasted hour.

Answered around 11:44
How were Mackenzie and her sister Danny treated differently?

Dom's mom told police Mackenzie was their golden child and they treated the other sister like a piece of crap — she's the pretty one, the smart one, the other one's got problems. On jail calls Natalie is heard screaming at Danny while speaking softly to Mackenzie.

Answered around 24:19
What did Dom's brother Angelo tell police about the relationship?

Angelo said Mackenzie would accuse Dom of cheating and threaten to hurt herself when he tried to break up — "if you break up with me I'm gonna kill myself." He blocked her number because she blew up his phone, and said her behaviour escalated as she got older.

Answered around 41:29
What happened in the days just before the crash?

Angelo told investigators that in July Dom was repeatedly trying to break up with her, and a couple of days before the crash she was hitting him while he drove on the highway. He pulled over and had someone else drive the car home, scared she would make him crash.

Answered around 46:37
Is there evidence Mackenzie was doing sex work before the crash?

Dom's messages accuse Mackenzie of letting a man pay to use her feet about nine months earlier, which she says happened while they were broken up. Prosecutors had a section on possible prostitution; police found nude photos on her phone but no clear proof anything was sold.

Answered around 54:39
Key Quote

“I'm sorry if I find marijuana not that dangerous as I find alcohol or cocaine or whatever.”

— Steve Shirilla, Warm Milk Controversy, at 11:06▶ listen at 11:06
Key Quote

“you better fix what you ruined or I will fail Polaris school”

— Mackenzie Shirilla, Warm Milk Controversy, at 15:20▶ listen at 15:20
Key Quote

“She is their golden child.”

— Dom's mom, Warm Milk Controversy, at 24:19▶ listen at 24:19
Key Quote

“anyone that doesn't know me should keep their mouth shut personally.”

— Steve Shirilla, Warm Milk Controversy, at 26:39▶ listen at 26:39

Cite this

“Warm Milk Controversy.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/ca05dec2-017c-4888-bda3-ab746f266395/episodes/0fce57a2-9640-45a6-b196-28ac058e9b71/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_dcd5bedc56d2d76afdf56781728c4a40_63040496.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/warm-milk-controversy.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?