A preprint across 60 animal species finds the nuclear-to-cytoplasm ratio, not shared genes, times zygotic genome activation.
Not a shared set of genes. The authors land on the nuclear-to-cytoplasm ratio, the amount of genome relative to yolk and cytoplasm in the egg. They see a robust correlation between that N to C ratio and the onset of the maternal-to-zygotic transition, what they call a deeply conserved molecular logic.
Answered around 21:06Yes. They plot the time of ZGA against the nuclear-to-cytoplasm ratio, each species a dot along a line, and take a statistical R value. For a new species you use genome size as the numerator, divide by cytoplasm volume measured in microns under the microscope, then read the predicted time off that correlative line.
Answered around 22:12Vincent notes the onset varies between one and 14 cell cycles across all the organisms they looked at, and Nels confirms it. That decouples ZGA from any fixed division number: it is not that everyone reaches the eighth division and switches over, it is the contents present and the ratios of them.
Answered around 23:18Sixty different species, 61 Nels guesses, of animal embryo time courses spanning 13 phyla and about 700 million years of divergence from a common ancestor. Existing data covered 23 species; the authors more than doubled that, getting embryos from 38 more, out through insects, nematodes, tardigrades, cnidarians and ctenophores.
Answered around 13:37Frogs, zebrafish and fruit flies are the quote-unquote fast developers, getting through those first 14 cell cycles in relatively short time. Mammals, ourselves included, are the slowpokes. Nels suggests ecology is under the hood: externally fertilized fish face predator-prey life-or-death scenarios, so churning through cell cycles and swimming away pays.
Answered around 17:35In almost all the species, zygotic gene activation happens before gastrulation, the formation of the special layers in the embryo. Nels says that makes intuitive sense: maternal transcripts have only so long a half-life, and the sophisticated work of gastrulation and beyond needs a regulatable embryonic genome already switched on.
Answered around 24:18The genes upregulated first in the handoff from maternal transcripts are generally short and contain very few introns, with short three prime UTRs. The authors imply relatively simple regulation, since this has to happen fast and these transcribe quickly. The ZGA genes they identify tend to be group or even species specific.
Answered around 27:08One of their ideas: activation occurs when some maternally deposited protein or nucleic acid acting on the DNA is titrated enough after rounds of genome replication, and then stops working. They suggest histones as a candidate, so you lose the maternal histones and make your own with different specificities. The ratio also connects to cell cycle length.
Answered around 40:33No. The authors say there have been so many rule-breaking events over 700 million years that you cannot trace backward from today's diversity in timing and features to what ZGA looked like in the common ancestor or in early, ancient animal species. Too many variables in this biology can be messed around with.
Answered around 28:16The maternally provided genes are a more common, shared set, and mainly involve regulation of the cell cycle, the instruction book for one cell to become two and two to become four, plus RNA processing so the RNAs get translated into the enzymes and structural components of the early embryo. They are deposited as mRNAs before fertilization.
Answered around 29:58“I'm Vincent Racaniello, and you're listening to the podcast on the biology behind what makes us tick.”
“Hey Vincent, greetings from Elde Lab Studio.”
“Time to perk up and get into the genetic game, kiddo.”
“What I found interesting is that the onset varies between one and 14 cell cycles”
“It's an egg timer.”
“We have to thank our mothers, right?”
“Zygotic Genome Activation in Early Embryos.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO0125.m4a. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/zygotic-genome-activation-in-early-embryos.html.